I hear what you're saying. I just haven't been able to figure out any logical or "technical" reason that changing the FE line of the combined audio would provide the varying results you encountered.
Just thinking out loud here......and asking all of you other CTX3030 users to feel free and chime in.......the FE/Conductive value of a target doesn't change when you alter your programs. The way we analyze them or interpret them might. But the FE and CO values of the target remain the same. In Bryan's scenario, since the audio response did change, something must have either changed in the manner the target signal was analyzed, or in the manner he was able to hear it.
In Bryan's examples.....when the bottom and top bins of the combined audio tone were separated at ferrous line 24, his detector had a degraded audio response on targets with a TID of 12 - 39. Not a chirp or blip. Nothing but low tones. We know that, with the horizontal line set at 24, a target with a ferrous value of 24 or less should be "sent" to one of the bins above the combined audio horizontal line. And when a target is "sent" above that horizontal combined audio line, the tone you hear will be based on the conductive value. Which conductive tone you hear will depend on how you set the audio tones in each of the conductive bins. For the sake of argument, lets say Bryan had his CTX set up to send a 39 conductive to one of the upper bins on the right hand side. In that regard, unless something interfered with the target analysis or the audio response, that target should have been sent to a bin above the line and to the right side. And, with the minimal amount of discrimination he was using,(just the FE 35 line and a few boxes in the lower right hand corner of the screen) he should have heard the tone associated with that bin. Based on his description, I'd suggest that would be a high tone. For reasons yet unknown, when he changed his combined audio horizontal line to FE 32, he got a strong audio high tone on the targets with a TID of 12-39. That makes sense because when you detect a target with an FE value smaller than where you have the combined audio horizontal line, the target should go to one of the bins above that line.
So why does his audio response "go away" when he uses Combined audio with the horizontal line at 24......but is loud and clear when he moves that horizontal line on Combined audio to 32? Since he was running with minimal discrimination, the CTX3030 should not have discriminated out the target with a TID of 12-39, regardless of whether the combined audio horizontal line was set at 24 or 32. In both situations, the target shouldould have been sent to one of the conductive bins for the audio response associated with that bin. (you will get a tone for that target, as long as the bin don't include rejected target ID #s for the specific target). Since the target FE/CO value did not change, and since the only thing changed was the horizontal line in his Combined audio settings, it seems to me that either the target signal was altered, or the audio response was masked, when he used the 24 line.
Bryan....could you check your two programs to make sure ALL of the other settings are the same, except for the placement of the Combined audio horizontal line? Specifically check for discrimination blocks, Target Separation mode, parameters of each bin and the tones assigned to each bin. I'm wondering if there could be something different between the programs that could be altering the audio response of your target, not necessarily the ability of the CTX to detect the target. Without knowing what appeared on the screen with each program, I hesitate to venture a guess. Another suggestion I would have would be to eliminate ALL of the discrimination and see if you get the same results in both of your programs with all targets accepted. Hang in there, there are folks on this forum who help us figure this out. HH Randy
Randy I know what is happening ,Try this test -0- (- meaning nail 0 meaning coin - meaning nail ) Put the nails and coin on the ground 1/8 inch apart ferrous line set to 32 I prefer 35 but just put it at 32 okay ,Now disc out the nails31 to 35 so we don't hear the nails . You will get a high tone okay,
Now set the ferrous line to 24 you well get a low tone no-dig signal .
The reason being is if you switch to high trash and run the same pattern except your in high trash and in conduct 4 tone now that coin with the nails well id at 27.45 to 29.45 which is the true spot where the coin well read on the screen. You have to have the 31 to 35 line disc out otherwise you well get 3 high tones
If you sweep the nails and coin east to west your id well be in the 27.45 to 29.45 area , if you sweep north and south it well build a trace at 12.39 to 12.41 because it's trying to push it to the 12 line . This is ferrous coin combine
Know in 4 tone conduct east west will try to build at the 27.45 to 29.45 area north south id well lock on in this area with a cursor .
I was using 3 inch nails size matters and well change where the cursor lands .
i:m trying to make a video on this and I'm half done .
I have been running conduct and combine at the same time you can see in my post where I was going back and forth where i said combine does not work as it suppose to but it does you have to disc the nails out other wise you well get low high low where as the nails disc out you well only get the high .
But the ferrous line has to be set below the 29 line otherwise you well get low low low because that coin comes in at 27.45 to 29.45 which is it's true id mixed with nails .
Now a nickel will up average with the iron it well read 27.30 to 29.35 in high trash 4 tone conduct same as ferrous coin combine but when swept north south ferrous coin combine well try to build a curser on the 12 line or above where as high trash 4 tone conduct will build it at 27.30 to 29.40 .
Randy the fe and co # change when the target is mixed with iron because there so close together it is looking at them as one. As far as the target being degraded it really is not because a coin with nails is giving you it's true fe and co #s
sube I have a theory on how minelab set up the fe co# s you see in the stock pattern where the fe line is set to I think 20 or 21 this is where all targets with iron come in at ( that minelab was sure there was a coin with iron or other good non ferrous item ) Put it this way that 21. 45 was going to 90 percent coin or other good object another words a no brain er . That was given a high tone .
Now compare it to a 29.45 a lot harder to decipher so minelab wants to make all targets go low at 22.45 to 35 .45 and all targets go high at (21.45 to 12.45 go high these are no brain er iron coin or other good target combos okay)
As you notice if minelab was to set there factory program fe line to 35 and have everything go high with iron people would be going crazy .
Now it's great to be able to adjust your fe line to 35 but your going to get more highs and more falsing with nails this is where skill comes in .
But with that fe line set at 21 your not going to hear a high tone for a 22.45 to 35 .45 when a coin is tight with iron where that coin signal is mixed with iron and say it's true reading on the fe and conductive side is
27.45
Now nails are not the same you have friendly nails these nails will disc out no problem east west and north south . then you have what I call bastard nails that will disc out east and west but high tone north and south.
A nail laying east west is easy to disc out but when north south some nails you can't disc out ( bastard nail ) But by knowing what to look for switching from ferrous coin combine to 4 tone conduct you will be able to disc these out by audio and what the cursor is doing on the screen.( most of them )
My video will show this also disc out the last 3 lines on the right side will cure some bastard nails from 12.48 12.49 and 12.50 from the 12 line down to the 35 line. People will ask why disc these out (i would say what have you found here)
But since we can go below the 21 line we can analize and see if we can make a coin stand out at 29.45 . I like that because there are more targets here than clean hit's left .
I'm trying to get this video out so give me some time
sube