Jim West Pa said:
Mr X WILL get his "rewards". He's a GOOD MAN pure and simple.
the only greed I see here is the land owner who just got thousands of dollars of old silver recovered for him and did not have the decency to offer anything for his time and efforts.
I don't call it greed to think Mr. X deserves a small reward like 5-10% to recover this massive cache, if he did not find it the land owner may have never got it.
Greed is a powerful thing. I do not know how many houses I have been too where the landowner tells me I can keep whatever I find, and when they see me dig up old coins, instantly greed kicks in and they start thinking I am digging priceless coins from their property (that they never knew were there to begin with) and then they ask for the coins.........AFTER they gave me their word I was free to keep ANYTHING I found. That is pure dishonesty and leaves a bad taste in my mouth when a homeowner does that to me.
Now I know this was NOT the situation here, because it was stated Mr X agreed to do it for free, I am merely giving an example of greedy landowners.