Find's Treasure Forums

Welcome to Find's Treasure Forums, Guests!

You are viewing this forums as a guest which limits you to read only status.

Only registered members may post stories, questions, classifieds, reply to other posts, contact other members using built in messaging and use many other features found on these forums.

Why not register and join us today? It's free! (We don't share your email addresses with anyone.) We keep email addresses of our users to protect them and others from bad people posting things they shouldn't.

Click here to register!



Need Support Help?

Cannot log in?, click here to have new password emailed to you

Changed email? Forgot to update your account with new email address? Need assistance with something else?, click here to go to Find's Support Form and fill out the form.

Vaquero depth vs Outlaw disc

jahu_bluszcz

New member
Hi,

i am just one small step before picking up one of them (I can buy outlaw with single 8'' even cheaper than vaquero :) ).
I read almost everything which i can google :) I found a lot about vaquero and just something about outlaw. What bother me at most is lack of comments about outlaw after let say one year hunting.
How outlaw works during the time? I read couple post about problems with return button. How you thing it is incidental or more common problem? What you thing about its depth after the time?
The most important i thing you will stay with it or not and why.

The last question which can help me.
I read few posts about outlaw disc especially i like 53silver post. However i am not sure what "better" is mean in this case? Is it mean that i can more easily separate bottle caps or pull taps from coins?

I will be glad if you can answer just one of my questions or left some advice.
 
My Thoughts on the Outlaw...

Retune Button very buggy on many units (mine failed twice)
Many problems with disc pot. Way negative or way positive in just a hair turn (Rusty has confirmed many of these as well)
Not very HOT on silver.
Super hot on gold

With all of that said, I obviously got a bad unit. That had me hating Tesoro for a while and bitter I'd just spent $600 for a lemon. After many therapy sessions and discussing with my psychologist, I feel better now....HeHe.. It's tough for me to give a better review since 95% of the time I've had it, It has been off. I have found some good stuff, don't get me wrong, it's deep on gold , very deep. I find lower conductive stuff much, much deeper than coins and silver. I had a lot of trouble Ground Balancing for a while and spoke with Rusty for like an hour, yes, the man talks a lot!!!!...LOL.. He had me go outside and try his method and immediately verified my GB switch was bad. The switch had always been that touchy from day one so I had been hunting with a bad GB setting all along. Maybe this was cause for depth issues? Maybe. I also find the Retune much to fast. Even ground balancing, you must be quick or it will retune the threshold and you think your good. All of this has been resolved and i'm ready for some real reviews, but for now, that's all I got!!

Good Luck
 
I don't own either so I can't help you with depth or features, but after buying a Tejon, I ended up buying both the 5.75" and 10"x12" search coils and lower poles separately. Tesoro still has the Outlaw packaged, at a great price, with all three coils and three lower poles to make changing the coils a snap. I get a lot of use out of the three different search coils, potentially more value than any minor depth difference between machines.
 
Tesoro has had some problems with the re-tune button on some of the Outlaws that were sold. If you buy new, it's covered by a lifetime warranty. If you are not the original owner, you will most likely be charged a small fee to fix the defective switch. Another thing after pinpointing or first starting out you'll need to switch to the all metal mode with the coil in the air away from any targets before switching to the discriminate mode or the discriminate mode will be de-tuned. That's part of the beast but it's not a big deal since you can do it quickly by pushing the red button all the way in. That's puts it in the all metal mode. The Vaquero has more depth, but it doesn't have the audio tone quality that the Outlaw has. Also the Outlaw runs smoother for me around iron laden sites. Both are great detectors and are a lot of bang for the buck. You can't go wrong with either. I've found some really good finds with both.

If you're getting good buys on both, get both of them and compare for yourself. Keep the one you like the most and sell the other one.

Good Luck!

tabman
 
Tab, as good as some of 53Silvers video's are, and believe me, I bought the Outlaw after watching his videos, I believe his description of the Retune button was very misleading. Watch the video again and tell me if i'm wrong. He spoke of temperature fluctuations, optimizing the machine, etc... He said press as many times as you like as often as you like to keep the machine optimized. Not knocking him, just think it was way off as to what it really does.
 
Idxpro, 53Silver is right on target with his video demonstrating the Outlaw. Make sure when you push the 're-tune' button that the coil is not close to a target in the ground. Better yet have the coil about a foot or more above the ground. If it's close to a target it will de-tune to the target and the detector will not detect as deep in the discrimination mode. Just keep in mind that the re-tune button carries over into the discrimination mode on the Outlaw and that the discrimination mode is de-tuned when you first turn the detector on and after pinpointing until you push the 're-tune' button all the way in or switch to the all metal auto mode with the coil away from any target. It's not a problem for those who can grasp that.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hde_YatsVyA

tabman
 
so far i have found the Vaquero to be no deeper with the 5.75" coil in this ground , but my ground is mineralized, the advantage of the vaquero is if you want to relic hunt in all metal , then the Vaquero is a lot deeper , the no motion all metal is interesting as it can do some things in the mineralized ground by detuning that is interesting , I would rather grab the outlaw if hunting a ball field or park , but if the ground is milder the VAQ will be deeper .
 
I cant speak to the Vaq, and be aware that I used the Outlaw as a new member of the MD community, but in my humble opinion if you have mild ground, don't bother with the Outlaw. Save 300$ and get a Silver uMax. If you want to worry about pushing a button all the way in, then half way in, then half way in with the coil in the air, or all the way in after switching to Disc, or switching to disc first then half way in but not over a target, or half way in when in disc or in AM but not over a target then all the way in after you're done pinpointing, etc, etc, etc, then grab that Outlaw. Yes, that is an inaccurate exaggeration, but it felt like that was the case at times. I got tired of worrying about under what circumstance you can and should push a button and under what circumstance it should be half way or all the way, and to worry if you forget or inadvertently do it wrong you could end up hunting for hours with a 2-3 inch max depth while disc-ing out the good targets. That is NOT an exaggeration. It just wasnt worth the hassle to have to be aware that a touch of a button could screw up the day's hunt.

I have yet to hear anyone say the Outlaw's re-tune button is an asset in the field, but plenty that say its a pain in the butt. The Outlaw (and Silver) does a fine job of pinpointing without that button and many forum members have stated they dont even use it. To be clear-- It doesn't make the Outlaw a bad machine, just one that is not very forgiving. If you've been at this for decades and used dozens of machines, the button might not be a big deal to you. If your experience is limited, it might turn out otherwise. If you need manual ground balance, the Outlaw is still a good bargain with the three coils, you'll just have to deal with the button (not a big deal for some, a very big deal to others) or just not use it. Again, many here do just that.

So, the good things --I loved the sound, the stability (virtually EMI proof in my experience), and the decent depth (easily hits a silver dime at 6-7 inches), and the three coils.

The Bad-- that darn button, touchy ground balance knob (but mine wasnt as bad as IDXpro's), and you can get a Silver that shares all of the good things (except the coils) at half the price, IF you can do without a manual GB.

As far as the Vaq goes, I'm sure you've read how stinkin' deep that machine goes when super-tuned in AM. If that's your thing, I would jump on one of those. Ive heard the Disc isnt very useful when super-tuned but its a pretty deep machine when not super-tuned and the disc works fine in that setting, or so Ive read. I have thought about a Vaq several times but I haven't gotten into many relic hunting situations yet. When I do, that will be my first choice for a new detector (if the new Cazador doesnt fit the bill).

Hope that helps you with your decision. Whichever way you go, let us know how things turn out and post your experiences here!
 
The Outlaw may have one button and one knob too many for some novice users. Mojotrout is right about the Silver
 
mojotrout said:
I cant speak to the Vaq, and be aware that I used the Outlaw as a new member of the MD community, but in my humble opinion if you have mild ground, don't bother with the Outlaw. Save 300$ and get a Silver uMax. If you want to worry about pushing a button all the way in, then half way in, then half way in with the coil in the air, or all the way in after switching to Disc, or switching to disc first then half way in but not over a target, or half way in when in disc or in AM but not over a target then all the way in after you're done pinpointing, etc, etc, etc, then grab that Outlaw. Yes, that is an inaccurate exaggeration, but it felt like that was the case at times. I got tired of worrying about under what circumstance you can and should push a button and under what circumstance it should be half way or all the way, and to worry if you forget or inadvertently do it wrong you could end up hunting for hours with a 2-3 inch max depth while disc-ing out the good targets. That is NOT an exaggeration. It just wasnt worth the hassle to have to be aware that a touch of a button could screw up the day's hunt.

I have yet to hear anyone say the Outlaw's re-tune button is an asset in the field, but plenty that say its a pain in the butt. The Outlaw (and Silver) does a fine job of pinpointing without that button and many forum members have stated they dont even use it. To be clear-- It doesn't make the Outlaw a bad machine, just one that is not very forgiving. If you've been at this for decades and used dozens of machines, the button might not be a big deal to you. If your experience is limited, it might turn out otherwise. If you need manual ground balance, the Outlaw is still a good bargain with the three coils, you'll just have to deal with the button (not a big deal for some, a very big deal to others) or just not use it. Again, many here do just that.

So, the good things --I loved the sound, the stability (virtually EMI proof in my experience), and the decent depth (easily hits a silver dime at 6-7 inches), and the three coils.

The Bad-- that darn button, touchy ground balance knob (but mine wasnt as bad as IDXpro's), and you can get a Silver that shares all of the good things (except the coils) at half the price, IF you can do without a manual GB.

As far as the Vaq goes, I'm sure you've read how stinkin' deep that machine goes when super-tuned in AM. If that's your thing, I would jump on one of those. Ive heard the Disc isnt very useful when super-tuned but its a pretty deep machine when not super-tuned and the disc works fine in that setting, or so Ive read. I have thought about a Vaq several times but I haven't gotten into many relic hunting situations yet. When I do, that will be my first choice for a new detector (if the new Cazador doesnt fit the bill).

Hope that helps you with your decision. Whichever way you go, let us know how things turn out and post your experiences here!

Damn Mojo, you just explained my frustration at times with that thing..lol. Now imagine a faulty button that sometimes stayed in the pushed in position but was in the half position. Or half position but not pushed in at all. Or pushed in but no change at all. Or the crazy overload that only shuting it down and restarting would fix it. I wanted to wrap that thing around the fence post and came very close. Then I remembered when i did that to my weedwacker when it wouldnt start but thats another story. Parto my frustration was due to the "other" forum members telling me it was user error and the machine was fine. I took my nephew out once and let him run my f2. We went to freshly turned corn field. He found a bunch of stuff and i found crap. After a couple hours i waive a quarter under the coil and got maybe 3" max. It was detuned the whole time. I shut it down and restarted and it went into overload. I went to the car, got a fresh battery and the same thing. I pushed the button like 30 times fast and it was fixed. In my case i never knew what position it was "really" in due to the faulty button. Unfortunately as a newb to this type of machine i hunted for months not knowing any better.
 
Thanks all for your hints and advices. The only reason which I consider outlaw is "better" disc (again 53Silver) and nice look :). However if vaquero and it is question to you, can discriminate foil and still get nickle coin he is my man :).

Few more words about me. I lived in Poland so i can buy tesoro only with 2 years warranty (it is not so sweet like in US). I am hunting mostly on a fields with a lot of nails and maybe not a lot but still very disturbing pieces of foil.
Coins, buttons, bullets, shells and wars relics like buckles it is what interesting me the most.

From time to time i am searching around old roads in very trashy areas. A lot of (foil, cans, bottle caps ...)
Right now i have Garrett ace 150. It is good with nails but not foil and pull taps. In trashy it sounds like Super Mario Brothers game :) which makes me crazy.
What i want to from my new detector? Reliability, very good disc and separation, depth and clear minimalistic interface.

I know , there are not silver bullet and probably i should buy 2 metals detectors, however today i can effort for a one.

After knowing few things more about me what would you advice?
 
One more thing.
If i decide to buy Vaquero which coil would be better for discrimination and target separation standart 9x8 or 12x10" Widescan.
I am asking because a read a lot of confusing posts and tests.
 
jahu_bluszcz said:
One more thing.
If i decide to buy Vaquero which coil would be better for discrimination and target separation standart 9x8 or 12x10" Widescan.
I am asking because a read a lot of confusing posts and tests.

It is a fact that using DD coils the disc is going to be a little less precise and a bit more sloppy...just the nature of the beast.
Not a ton but there is a difference and depending on the sites I hunt and the amount of specific trash this difference does matter so I choose coils as needed if I know what is waiting for me.

I hunt some very trashy sites, unbelievably trashy where I have dug 5-10 pieces of trash out of a square foot area at all depths just to get a clear place to ground balance my Vaq.
Some say that long and thing scanning field on the DD is great for snaking though trash, but I believe the coil is so big on the 10X12 that the smaller sniper coil would work much better due to less chance of having more than one target under the coil.
I seem to have a much better time dealing with trash areas like this using the 9X8 compared to the 10X12, and I do have a smaller concentric to use when I am not to lazy to mount it.

There are 2 types of trash that I deal with at super heavy trash sites most of the time that really bug me, tabs of all kinds and high tone crimped bottle caps.
When I use my Tesoro's and any coils I always thumb the knob past the fade out point and then slowly turn back and listen to how the target comes in.
80% of the tabs, the ones that are not shallow and laying flat and perpendicular in the soil will come in pretty noisy with some crackles and clicks and I have dug enough of these in the past to believe most of the time these will be trash.
Good targets like coins and rings will just come in solid and clear for me 99% of the time doing this, they are just there.
About 20% of that tab trash will do that too and come in solid but I am grateful that I can avoid digging most of them and even though I never know 100% what I am not digging I have good confidence I am not skipping over the good stuff and the what ifs don't bother me so I am fine with that.
Using any coil, the standard, the sniper or the 10X12 DD this seems to work fine but I think it is a little more precise when I use the concentrics vs. the DD.

Those stupid high tone bottle caps are totally different when using both types of coils.
Most of them will come in high but at the very top of the disc level they are not there on the concentric standard coil, you have t turn the knob down a hair to bring them back in and that way I can tell the difference between these and coins 99% of the time.
Using the big DD a few of these do this also, but the disc is slightly less tight on my Vaq in this area, most other detectors using DD coils also, and most of these caps won't disc out and come in nice and solid and hit hard like high tone coins.
There is a way to deal with these using any coils and especially the DD's on my F70 which has a screen.
By rimming the edge of the coil over these things I will get a low iron grunt or tone when my disc is set low and I see numbers drop into iron range so this is a fast and efficient way to avoid these things.
Rimming good targets there is never a drop like this.
Actually, the same thing works on my Vaq, but the problem I have is to see this effect you have to turn the disc knob down to iron when rimming and see if you get a signal...and even though it works it does take a bit more time which frustrates me because when I am out there hunting in the zone I am all about moving fast, efficiently and digging volume and I would rather dig a high volume of good targets than wasting a lot of time on suspected trash targets.
Because of masking it is probably a good idea to dig this trash anyway, but I hunt in a few areas with a severe problem with these, a veritable carpet of caps at all depths and there are still enough good target signals in there to keep me happy and digging so I don't worry about it so much.
I suppose if I used a Tejon with that double disc this rimming technique would work much better and be extremely fast, but I don't have one so I deal with it the fastest way I know and when using the Vaq and the DD I just dig them.
A picture below of a typical 4 hour hunt at one of these pop top filled parks.

When it comes to the Outlaw, the disc is a bit different than the Vaq with a wider range near the top, according to 53Silver it can disc out a dime but still get quarters, and that just might make a difference on everything I talked about above and make the whole process much easier but I have never swung one so I don't know.

When it comes to foil and can slaw that turning the knob thing down to listen to how they come in thing works well on both types of coils on my, and I have a high tone Vaq and most aluminum, no matter what size from small to cans, just gives me a very annoying tone that grates on my last nerve and as much as I hate that tone it is very helpful in distinguishing trash from treasure so even though I once had a thought I would change my Vaq back to a low tone I decided this ability is worth keeping if just for this purpose.

One thing about the big DD coil, if you want to cover large, wide open areas that usually have less trash than the examples above, this thing works great.
I don't feel I am missing much with that long scanning field and I have found great targets, even gold, running around sites like this moving and swinging that coil way faster than I probably should but I do that because I have great confidence in that coil and the speed of the Vaq that working together can alert me to targets I pass over even if it is quick, short tone.
If I get one I go back and examine the target further and this works well for me.
 
I will say this, the guys on this forum are very loyal to the Tesoro brand. Many take offense at any criticism of ANY Tesoro model. I am not loyal to any brand but do enjoy all of my machines of all brands. They are all different and good at certain things. NOW, if you speak with people who aren't so loyal, and simply state it like it is, you will get much different reviews. It's tough sometimes on these forums because many feel the need to defend their brand. It's just human nature too, no disrespect to anyone, it's just the truth. Now in my opinion, I still feel a beep dig machine to be much less "productive and effective" to be a great coin shooter. There are just too many things that have the same properties as a coin for a single tone beep to tell me if it's coin or otherwise. And even if I mastered a beep dig machine, it would still just be much too time consuming to thumb, wiggle, lift coil, etc... Never have owned a Vaq, but judging from everything I have read on many forums, I would never get one for mostly coin shooting, just not the right machine for it. With that said, I don't think the Outlaw is either. In the woods with very little trash or going for the gold, the Outlaw hits very, very hard and is great for that application.
 
I'm curious to hear Reiver's input on Coin shooter machine....F2 or Vaq?
 
x99 said:
@REVIER
That is a load of trash. Someone should pay you for this.

This was a 100 year old park back in Birmingham, Ala.
I have found great things at this park, but the amount of trash you have to fight through is ridiculous.
I have been there after some large gatherings from groups like family picnics and once some sort of a fraternity function and even though there are trash cans all over the place you would not believe how much trash was left in these areas and even just thrown on the ground in the parking lot.
It is like most of these pigs just opened the door on their car, dumped the trash and just drove away.

I figure masking is a huge problem here, more than at many of my sites due to the volume of trash, so even though I knew that most of these signals were trash I dug them anyway and rechecked the area.
This was the park I mentioned where I have to dig trash just to get a clear area to GB.
A few of the great things I found here in the past makes this effort worth it, but luckily most sites I hunt aren't quite as bad.
 
x99 said:
@REVIER
That is a load of trash. Someone should pay you for this.

"If you ain't digging the trash, you ain't digging the cash" There are so many trash targets that mimic great finds, even with a great Target ID metal detector with all the bells and whistles, you will get fooled by the trash. Are beep and dig methods the best stratagy in an inner city trashed out park? I would say no, get the best Target ID machine you can afford. Location plays a role at this, I use a good Target ID machine where I want to be more carefull in the holes I dig, then at some of my old abandoned houses in the country, I will use my Beep & Dig machines with a relic shovel. One of these days when I learn to post pictures, I will show and tell some of my finds that have come in at trash ID, for instance my Indian Wars Crossed Sabre Hat Pin thad ID'ed just like about two dozen beavertail pulltabs I dug in that yard to find the hat pin.
 
Idxpro said:
I'm curious to hear Reiver's input on Coin shooter machine....F2 or Vaq?

Actually, since I used the F2 for 3 years and now the F70, and a Vaq and a Compadre for 4 years and thoroughly enjoy hunting with both kinds and still do, I think in my heart of hearts I am maybe one of those that isn't so brand loyal to a fault.
To answer your question I find a ton of coins with the Tesoros, but I do that also with the Fishers and I suppose because of the tones AND the screen info using screens for me is a bit faster.
More accurate, I don't know, I seem to find a large volume of coins with all of them and I feel like my ability to recognize and avoid trash using both kinds is pretty close to equal, but as far as really deep stuff my Vaq and my F70 can both get down there but there seems to be a bit more accurate info on these deep targets because of the screen.
When it comes to the crazy deep ones, like 12" and deeper using large DD coils on both the F70 and the Vaq or 9-10" or more on the F70 using the standard 10" elliptical coil, most of the time the screen info is either unreliable or nonexistent, and in those instances I just revert back to getting all my usable info from just the tones.
Because the F70 does have the option of 2 different sampling speeds and 8 different tone settings that you can switch to when examining those deep targets I guess that would throw the advantage over to the F70 side in those cases when I want to be a little more decisive when choosing to dig, but to be honest using either kind these really deep signals I get cause my curiosity to raise up high so using either I usually just dig the thing just to see what it is.
As deep as my Vaq is I do seem to be getting a little deeper with the F70 if I max it out, but when I used the Vaq full time it was in Ala. soil where nobody could get great depth and when I moved to Kansas with much better soil by that time the F2 was working so well for me that I rarely pulled the Vaq out except at very few sites where I cared about going super deep so that comparison really doesn't have enough data to be reliable.
 
REVIER said:
I have found great things at this park, but the amount of trash you have to fight through is ridiculous.
I have been there after some large gatherings from groups like family picnics and once some sort of a fraternity function and even though there are trash cans all over the place you would not believe how much trash was left in these areas and even just thrown on the ground in the parking lot.
It is like most of these pigs just opened the door on their car, dumped the trash and just drove away.

I know how you feel. It's the same in my area. These pigs are cleaning their backyards only "for others", but if no one sees it they have no problem with throwing trash in parks/woods. I also have a huge problem with other detectorists, who not even think about filling their holes. It is ridiculous.


Hombre said:
"If you ain't digging the trash, you ain't digging the cash" There are so many trash targets that mimic great finds, even with a great Target ID metal detector with all the bells and whistles, you will get fooled by the trash.
That's one of many reasons, why I want to sell the Deus and get a Tesoro. I got fooled many times by trash. And many times I decided not to dig because of an ID... It has to stop.
 
Top