They both are keepers in my opinion!
First off the 17 incher is an absolute monster! I didn't really know what to think of it when I first opened it up. Raymo made a post talking about how it hammers the deep coins.. He isn't blowing smoke! In a friends test garden it made a 10 inch quarter sound like it was 6 inches deep!
I am very impressed with the little 6 inch coil as well. I have spent more time using it so far.. One of my favorite places to take new equipment is an old farm house on park property. I have had made some awesome finds at this location. There are more nails than you can imagine, and the place has just been hunted to death by everyone! When I got the coils I took the 6 inch coil directly there. Hunting in combined all metal I put the little guy to work.. Right away I started pulling wheat cent after wheat cent. After working a small area for about 2 hours I ended up with a half dozen wheat pennies. That was the most coins I have ever found at this spot at one time.. Every coin i dug I had to remove nails from the hole to recover them! I went back tonight and changed up the settings a bit. I ended up pulling 2 more wheats and a silver 61 Rosy. Finding all those coins just blows me away.. Yeah they are not "amazing" finds.. But if you knew this location.. You would be pretty pumped about them as well..
This past Saturday I met up with my buddy Jim and we hit a few spots... I started of using the stock coil but then quickly switched back to the 6inch. I was able to pull few wheats and a 1874 Indian that was just barely under the surface. I have never found a coin of that age so shallow.. The next spot we hit up Jim has done a pretty good job of cleaning her out.. I figured this was a perfect opportunity to try out te big 17 inch coil. After about an hour I finally got a good coin signal with the depth meter jumping back and forth between 8, 9 and 10 inches. I opened up the hole and way down there recovered a 1897 GREEEEN Indian
The big coils weight isn't a problem at all, actually balanced very well.. Its also plenty sensitive to small objects.
If its in the budject I would definitely recommend both coils!
Another note... One thing that has me a little worried... I have been hunting pretty much in combined all metal since I received my CTX. I have had amazing success in my old hunting out spots with these settings.. Over the weekend I played around in a friends test garden.. He has a silver dime at 8 inches with a square nail on each side.. My combined settings performed well on every coins in his test garden except this particular one.. 50 conductive with a little discrimination hands down sounded better.. The detector picked up on the nails, gave a grunt and hardly registered on the coinm I honestly dont think I would have dug the signal my detector was giving me in combined
50 conductive with discrimination was a little jumper. But my ears knew without a doubt something was there. I wish I would have tried combined with a small amout of disc.
I set up a little pattern in 50 conductive and hunted the farm house again tonight. Thats whatp I was using when I found the silver rosy tonight.. I did get falsing and I did dig more nails than usual.. But there was a noticeable difference between the silver dime and large pieces of iron.. When I switched back and forth between combined and 50 conductive.. The iron grunt definitely over powered the coin signal. This is something I am definitely going to be spending more time testing. Hunting in one mode and switching to the other.. Hope I havent missed too much.. Only time will tell.
Good luck hunting everyone!
Derrelld
First off the 17 incher is an absolute monster! I didn't really know what to think of it when I first opened it up. Raymo made a post talking about how it hammers the deep coins.. He isn't blowing smoke! In a friends test garden it made a 10 inch quarter sound like it was 6 inches deep!
I am very impressed with the little 6 inch coil as well. I have spent more time using it so far.. One of my favorite places to take new equipment is an old farm house on park property. I have had made some awesome finds at this location. There are more nails than you can imagine, and the place has just been hunted to death by everyone! When I got the coils I took the 6 inch coil directly there. Hunting in combined all metal I put the little guy to work.. Right away I started pulling wheat cent after wheat cent. After working a small area for about 2 hours I ended up with a half dozen wheat pennies. That was the most coins I have ever found at this spot at one time.. Every coin i dug I had to remove nails from the hole to recover them! I went back tonight and changed up the settings a bit. I ended up pulling 2 more wheats and a silver 61 Rosy. Finding all those coins just blows me away.. Yeah they are not "amazing" finds.. But if you knew this location.. You would be pretty pumped about them as well..
This past Saturday I met up with my buddy Jim and we hit a few spots... I started of using the stock coil but then quickly switched back to the 6inch. I was able to pull few wheats and a 1874 Indian that was just barely under the surface. I have never found a coin of that age so shallow.. The next spot we hit up Jim has done a pretty good job of cleaning her out.. I figured this was a perfect opportunity to try out te big 17 inch coil. After about an hour I finally got a good coin signal with the depth meter jumping back and forth between 8, 9 and 10 inches. I opened up the hole and way down there recovered a 1897 GREEEEN Indian

The big coils weight isn't a problem at all, actually balanced very well.. Its also plenty sensitive to small objects.
If its in the budject I would definitely recommend both coils!
Another note... One thing that has me a little worried... I have been hunting pretty much in combined all metal since I received my CTX. I have had amazing success in my old hunting out spots with these settings.. Over the weekend I played around in a friends test garden.. He has a silver dime at 8 inches with a square nail on each side.. My combined settings performed well on every coins in his test garden except this particular one.. 50 conductive with a little discrimination hands down sounded better.. The detector picked up on the nails, gave a grunt and hardly registered on the coinm I honestly dont think I would have dug the signal my detector was giving me in combined

I set up a little pattern in 50 conductive and hunted the farm house again tonight. Thats whatp I was using when I found the silver rosy tonight.. I did get falsing and I did dig more nails than usual.. But there was a noticeable difference between the silver dime and large pieces of iron.. When I switched back and forth between combined and 50 conductive.. The iron grunt definitely over powered the coin signal. This is something I am definitely going to be spending more time testing. Hunting in one mode and switching to the other.. Hope I havent missed too much.. Only time will tell.
Good luck hunting everyone!
Derrelld