its pretty simple for me i work my butt off what i find i keep if metal detecting.
if i find a wallet and i have an example long time ago i was sitting in front of a cafe and was down on my luck and this truckie dropped his wallet full of cash thousands of dollars i could have pocketed it and took off but i gave it back to him, he grunted and kept going.
was out for a walk kid getting on the bus i happened to look in the bus stop seat he left his phone i picked it up and gave it to him, random finds where the person is near the find or i seen it happen i give it to them, work my ass off to find it metal detecting i own it because i worked hard for it. it really is that simple for me.
i had a kid ask me to look for his keys down the beach with my detector no probs i can do that !!
for me i drew a line in the sand to make it easy for me i work hard its mine! simple really.
chance finding with no effort on my part i have not worked for it hand it back if i can as in ID inside etc.
i am a beach hunter 1st and foremost and bugger that's hard work and i find i few goodies and they are mine mine mine no questions asked.
so in short no effort involved in the find give it back, work involved its my pay i own it.
this is how it works for me otherwise i would drive myself crazy and i brought a metal detector to find things and have fun. no guilty involved for me none whats so ever.
and at the end of the day people don't own anything we look after it for awhile then give to someone else and they look after it for awhile and on and on it goes, maybe something i found will go on in my family and get lost somewhere and be found by the descendant of the person who lost it, who knows??
its only bits of metal.
who would i give raw gold back too? its really not worth anything in human terms laying in the ground its worth nothing, pull it out and put some human terms of value on it.
the indigenous people of Australia would have been looking at tons and tons of gold just laying on the ground it was worth nothing to them because they put no value on it so its all relative, they might have used it to chuck at kangaroos or something but had no value to them.
food water and shelter had value to them as it does us the rest is fluff and excess so i don't mind picking up a bit of fluff now and then
and to fulfill my need to hunt as a man its in our blood we don't have to go out and hunt and kill food for the fam anymore so we have to satisfy that part of us to hunt some go fishing some metal detecting ..........ect.......
having gave my feelings on the matter i dont expect anybody to agree its a personal choice and full well respect what anyone chooses to do with their finds.
sorry you asked?