Well, as I said, I would try out the Harbor Freight and compare it to my Bounty Hunter. The Harbor Freight worked just fine. It actually had a greater range than the Bounty Hunter. Since the Harbor Freight was actually designed to detect nails in boards, I tried a couple of things. I used the end to search and I used if flat to search. Got pretty good results with both. I wish the Harbor Freight had a rounded point so I could probe into the soil a little better, but I found a tip from a bottle rocket on the 4th and will see if that works. With my headphones on, I couldn't hear the tone on the Harbor Freight one, and since it doesn't;t vibrate, I had to take my phones off to hear. But I can't hear the Bounty Hunter either. The light came in handy on one dig. I found a wheat about 5 inches down. I could probe and see where I was probing easily. I was under some trees and the sunlight was blocked out pretty well. As I said in my previous post, I gave the Harbor Freight to my nephew. He loved, it and I am waiting to see how it survives with a 10 year old. He thought it was great, of course, keeping in mind it helped him find his first coins on his first hunt. The Bounty Hunter seems to be better constructed, but it was built to probe coins and artifacts, not hunt nails. I was using it in sandy soil in the upper peninsula of Michigan. I live in Texas and the soil is heavy clay, and that could be an issue. The times I used the probes, both worked well. I would say for the price, the Harbor Freight might be a good beginners units.