Find's Treasure Forums

Welcome to Find's Treasure Forums, Guests!

You are viewing this forums as a guest which limits you to read only status.

Only registered members may post stories, questions, classifieds, reply to other posts, contact other members using built in messaging and use many other features found on these forums.

Why not register and join us today? It's free! (We don't share your email addresses with anyone.) We keep email addresses of our users to protect them and others from bad people posting things they shouldn't.

Click here to register!



Need Support Help?

Cannot log in?, click here to have new password emailed to you

Changed email? Forgot to update your account with new email address? Need assistance with something else?, click here to go to Find's Support Form and fill out the form.

People getting ticked off

In all the detecting i've done over the decades, looking back i've been kicked out only once and had an altercation with two teenage punks once in a city park.

It was at a hi school in a large city years ago on a Saturday in mid Summer-school out.
I stumbled onto clad heaven right outside the school's windows. My pouch was bulging with clad mostly pennies, most on or near the surface too.

When all of a sudden 'Hey YOU get the H out of here before i call the police'. It was the school's caretaker. Left without a word.
What i think, the only thing that made any sense why all the clad below the windows is the kids were flinging coins out the window when the teacher wasn't looking. :look:
Now why didn't i think of that when i was in hi-school. :lol:
 
" ..I figure they just meant on that particular day...I didnt ask specifics.. "

Mud, how could you be so horrible and lawless? Haven't you ever heard of the md'ing "code of ethics" ? I don't know how you sleep at night ! haha

Seriously now: I have heard of persons who got booted from certain spots, that do indeed interpret that to mean "for all times, and for all md'rs". So for example if you run into an irate school janitor having a bad day, it wouldn't be unusual for him to say something like "All the schools here are off-limits to md'ing". The embarassed md'r slinks away, and informs his buddies, club members, etc.... Pretty soon it's just taken as gospel fact.

For this reason, whenever someone comes on a thread asking "is detecting allowed at such & such city or county parks?". And then someone else comes on answering : "no". When you look closely at the "no" post, you almost have to wonder if the notion didn't get started for the very silly reasons we see here: That someone got booted in a fluke situation, or they did something silly like to go ask at city hall, and get an arbitrary opinion. Those things get put in print. And before long, it's just taken as fact.
 
Sometimes they're fluke situations but also could be a shot across the bow.

I learned a long time ago, when someone asks me to leave, these days i leave.... based on my past experiences when i didn't resulting in He|| to pay.
And i'm not only talking detecting here. If i am personally kicked out, i would not return. If i just 'heard' someone got kicked out, i'd test the waters dependant on risk vs. reward research.

As i and others have said here before, if there are no signs posted or known ordinances, i detect no matter what the 'rumors' are against it. You can always plead ignorance, apologize and leave if caught. No big deal.
For crysake metal detecting is not some heinous crime or felony (yet).
 
I like your approach Mud. However one place I loved to detect and found many, many wonderful old coins came crashing down one day from a town cop. I'll condense and make this the short version

Officer: "you can't ever come back here"

Officer: "I don't understand officer I have been coming here for a very long time"

Officer: "Look some guy came in here with a long handled shovel and dug the place up. Some kid came along (its now part of school property / ball field) and injured himself. I see you are very careful and fill your holes but this came down from the top. Next time I see you in here, I will have to arrest you. Oh, and this goes for all the schools and town property"

I then tossed my lesche digger into the back seat....that officer backed up with a surprised look on his face. I believe he was shocked at the long serrated blade that I was actually carrying on school property. Oops. He then demanded to see my drivers license. I guess he wanted to see if I was wanted lol

There is one place in this town I still detect. No one can see me unless they get out of their vehicle and walk into the woods. It is preserved as open space :)

Tom, for me, I am not taking any chances. I know there is an ordinance on the books that no one can damage or remove vegetation blah blah blah on the books so this officer could create a very bad day for me. I never asked the town as many have hunted this place for the last 40+ years. It took one idiot with a full size shovel (and not filling his gaping holes) to shut it down.



Tom_in_CA said:
" ..I figure they just meant on that particular day...I didnt ask specifics.. "

Mud, how could you be so horrible and lawless? Haven't you ever heard of the md'ing "code of ethics" ? I don't know how you sleep at night ! haha

Seriously now: I have heard of persons who got booted from certain spots, that do indeed interpret that to mean "for all times, and for all md'rs". So for example if you run into an irate school janitor having a bad day, it wouldn't be unusual for him to say something like "All the schools here are off-limits to md'ing". The embarassed md'r slinks away, and informs his buddies, club members, etc.... Pretty soon it's just taken as gospel fact.

For this reason, whenever someone comes on a thread asking "is detecting allowed at such & such city or county parks?". And then someone else comes on answering : "no". When you look closely at the "no" post, you almost have to wonder if the notion didn't get started for the very silly reasons we see here: That someone got booted in a fluke situation, or they did something silly like to go ask at city hall, and get an arbitrary opinion. Those things get put in print. And before long, it's just taken as fact.
 
Ouch! EPL....Yeah, he was pretty specific...:sadwalk: Since you've been hunting this place for such a long time, theres gotta be a way you can plead you are 'grandfathered' in....funny thing, I cant remember a post where ANY of us ever got actually arrested though, you know, cuffed and stuffed and all that....I remember Jimtn got rousted in Nashville last year much the same way you experienced...

As generally elder harmless taxpayers with long glorious records of community service, We have rights too...theres gotta be a way to get to the right man to circumvent this...at least a fellow should try to figure it out and get a 'personal dispensation' under your grandfather clause from some higher up..maybe print some official looking form off the internet even? :rofl: Have it signed and notarized by the local Judge or Chief of police?

Thats the same reason the cop told me, somebody dug the hell out of the park with big shovel, so now its off limits to all of us? How come we are punished for somebody elses 'crime'? its just unAmerican I tells you!

At least thats what I will say if I ever stand before a judge on account of poking around in the dirt with a screwdriver..:shrug:....oh, I had some rent a cops roll up on me while I was hunting a local College once while it was on holiday..no biggie, we talked a bit and they were cool...so those private schools a guy can get into even if theres a local bug about the public ones...
Mud
 
David,what you said about adopting a new strategy is right on. Most of us who have a brain are respectful of property and other people while we're there and know what to do. I can't be held responsible for other people's stupidity,unless it's my kids. I am going,using good judgement,and avoiding high traffic areas at high traffic times. With the advent of the cell phone people have the ability to call you in right now. Back in the day they probably would've forgotten about it by the time they got home to use their wall phone. It's a symptom of over crowding and expanding population. Competition for goods,resources,authority...it all counts. Where I think I need permission,I will make sure I have permission if I want to be there. Places I deem to be open to all will be hunted with care.
 
Harold said:
I lost about 80% of my sites the last year are two. Some is people with shovels new and old. And some is just to many people doing it nowadays so flying under the radar is impossible anymore. That is why I'm negative sometimes,But you would be too if you lost 80% of your sites. I think in 5 years from now no public property's will allow metal detecting.So all the manufactures better make and sell as many detectors as they can as hard times are to follow. These metal detecting shows they Sponser are going to cut there own throat.JMHO.

I can definitely understand how you feel Harold, as an old timer myself I've seen the hobby do a 180 degree turn around over the last thirty years. Yes, there are people with shovels running around all over the place (and now I'm seeing them in public parks and even private yards), many of them not knowing how to properly recover/preserve finds and these metal detecting shows surely don't help. Then there is this new obsession with everyone having to do a movie production to show their finds on You tube. Making movies for You tube wouldn't be so bad but too many of these people display the very worst practices that give our hobby a bad name and provide fuel to the people (IE archaeologist, many who despise us), who have been lobbying for years to have laws enacted to ban the hobby. Believe me when I say that these people are still hard at work trying to get our hobby banned. Do some research and look at some of the laws that are already in place in many areas/states (IE antiquities acts) some enacted quite recently and cover many of the historical artifacts (IE anything over 100 years old, and yes even on private property) that we all love to find. Their reasoning is that these metal detectorists are a bunch of criminals stealing, destroying and selling historical artifacts which belong to history and the American culture. What better ammunition can we give these people than posting videos showing people, many carelessly digging holes/fetching beautiful/valuable artifacts and then beating/scraping on them with their digging tools and many times in the case of coins rubbing the heck out of them. I cringe every time I see these types of things and can just see our enemies using these very videos (which are everywhere on line now) as evidence against us to make their case! If anything, we should be using (new technology & especially videos) as mechanisms to show the public and our enemies that we are respectful, responsible people who enjoy discovering and preserving our history/culture as much as they do!

In recent years I can't tell you how many times I've been met with the response when asking permission for instance "oh, you're one of those guys who runs around with a metal detector digging big holes all over the place". Believe me guys, the bad perceptions about our hobby are getting worse and if we don't do something to change those perceptions by policing our hobby ourselves, we will not have it in a few years.

Listed below are a few practices that have served me well in the hobby over the years:

- Make up a business type card with your picture and personal information (name, address, phone, occupation) to present to the owner when you approach them
- Explain the hobby and non-destructive methods used to retrieve finds (that shows that you respect their property)
- Tell them that you will show/share your finds with them and even offer to have them join in the fun with you (I always take an extra turn on and go type detector with me for that purpose)
- Never no never take a shovel in private yards or public parks (only use them in the woods or farm fields)
- Always try to leave the area (no matter where) such that no-one can tell that you were there once you leave (this in itself takes practice)
- Just my experience, you're more likely to get permission to hunt a private yard as a single person rather than in a group
- When metal detecting be as discrete as possible when digging and retrieving finds (I always kneel to dig and use a stout, sharp hunting knife, which can be carried discretely under my shirt/jacket)
- Especially in private yards and even in parks only detect when the ground is moist and only cut 180 degree plugs so as not to destroy the root system and have the grass die and cause brown spots
- When detecting moist manicured lawns even though you cut 180 degree plugs, Aerate the plug by using a slim screwdriver to punch holes in it after firmly tamping it down which will greatly reduce the chance of it dying and leaving a brown spot
- If detecting a prime old property and you find something interesting about the same age as the property, offer it to the owner as this can create good will and greatly increase your chances of being able to detect the property again
- One little trick, if you just can't wait until you get home to properly clean a find, especially a coin, always carry a small squirt bottle filled with water to remove the dirt and avoid rubbing/scratching it
- Finally, never detect property (even if it looks abandoned) unless you get permission from the owner or maybe the caretaker

JMHO

HH
 
It's all about rules and regulations other wise people will run amuck WAIT A SECONED HOW CAN YOU TRESPASS ON SCHOOLS GROUNDS IF IT'S A PUBLIC SCHOOL AND YOU PAY SCHOOL TAXES, AND THAT MAKES YOU THE PUBLIC.
SOME SCHOOLS BY ME NOW HAVE SIGNS NO TRESPASSING AND ARE FENCED IN AND LOCKED AFTER HOURS (]AND YOU CAN'T EVEN USE THE PLAY GROUND CHILDERN)
 
Top