I have looked at this from every possible angle. I am as unbiased as anyone you will hear from. I loved my Whites 6000DI PRO, but did not like the DFX. I really like my Explorer SE but did not care for the Excalibur. Now I am getting attached to the F-75.
I know exactly where you are coming from John, Bill and Charlie.
Charlie, I too am an RC Pilot. I taught myself how to fly, albeit with a trainer. I did crash and rebuild several times, but I made it. For me experience is the best teacher.
I stated, I have used Whites and Minelab in the past. I am just getting back into detecting after several years off and I bought an Explorer SE, and then started looking for a backup/second machine. I chose the F-75 based mostly on the input of a local detectorist and forum poster. Thanks Alton.
I read many reviews both good and bad. This had to be one of the most confusing experiences in my life. Some love the F-75 and some hate it. There seems to be no middle ground.
I then realized that there is one universal truth.
Although different detectors have different features, ALL VLF DETECTORS WORK IN BASICALLY THE SAME MANNER. They are combination transmitters/receivers. Any time you are generating and reading a magnetic field, or transmitting/receiving a radio signal you have to live with some basic physical principles. When you crank up the power, you open yourself up for interference. This interference can come from some unsuspected sources. For example, if you crank up the transmit power on a CB radio and start talking you can reach targets at amazing distances if the weather conditions are right. However, your neighbor might not be able to make out what you are saying because you are overloading his receiver. Also, your signal will bleed over to other channels/frequencies on nearby radios. I live close to a truck stop and back in the days before cable when, we used an aerial for reception, I have actually heard CB signals on my TV. By the same logic, when you open up a receiver, you open yourself up to increased interference (noise) levels.
Your detector is susceptible to this kind of interference. The hotter you run it, the more susceptible it is. Think of it as a radio transceiver. If you have two transmitters, one capable of 50 watts and the other capable of 100 watts, to get equal performance from them you will have to run the 50w unit wide open to get the same transmit power as the 100w unit at 50%. The same is true for detectors. The F-75 is a more powerful unit than WhizzBang 5000 (don't want to get specific). Therefore, your sensitivity setting will be lower on the F-75 to get the same relative performance as the WhizzBang running wide open. Turning up the sensitivity on the F-75 will give you more performance as long as there is no added interference.
I was not as prudent as Charlie. I bought my F75 on Friday, played with it for a couple of hours Friday night then took it to my first organized/seeded hunt on Saturday. Yes I got some chatter from nearby detectors until I switched frequencies. I ran the sensitivity up and down checking the effect on this chatter. I got frustrated for a split second then stopped to think the thing through logically. With 27 detectors within a small space I could get the F75 to behave properly by reducing the sensitivity and still pick up targets at least 6-7" deep. I pulled several coins from the middle of different kinds of trash. I know this because I did not take the time to learn to pinpoint properly with the F-75 before the hunt so I dug some relatively large diameter holes. There were also some holes with multiple dimes spaced about an inch or so apart. Three dimes, three signals from the F-75. Now, I love my Explorer SE and it is great in trash if you run ALL METAL/LONG. However the F75 gave me three distinct audio signals on close targets while running in motion discrimination. All in all I walked away with 15 silver dimes including several mercuries and an 1876 seated liberty, 3 V nickels, a war nickel, two buffalo's, two wheaties and a couple of others I don't remember off the top of my head. I think that's not a bad count for a newbie to organized hunting with a machine that I have no experience with.
Sorry for the rambling, but I thought the comparisons and info might prove helpful. Anyway, just my 2 cents worth.