Find's Treasure Forums

Welcome to Find's Treasure Forums, Guests!

You are viewing this forums as a guest which limits you to read only status.

Only registered members may post stories, questions, classifieds, reply to other posts, contact other members using built in messaging and use many other features found on these forums.

Why not register and join us today? It's free! (We don't share your email addresses with anyone.) We keep email addresses of our users to protect them and others from bad people posting things they shouldn't.

Click here to register!



Need Support Help?

Cannot log in?, click here to have new password emailed to you

Changed email? Forgot to update your account with new email address? Need assistance with something else?, click here to go to Find's Support Form and fill out the form.

GT Water Hunt- PP Mode Strikes Again! Some Bling, Some Silver, But More Importantly Some Good Karma Points...

Critterhunter

New member
Today I had intended to dry beach hunt in PP mode to re-grid an area I had already done in discriminate at a very mineralized beach where pin point mode has shown some merit to sounding off to targets that either null completely or choke out so bad that you have to wiggle right over them to get disc to sound off, while PP is easily telling me to pay attention.

Well, I changed decisions even though I was using my land shaft with meter, and not the stock shaft, which I use for when water hunting without a meter and the GT either chest mounted or stuck on a back shaft extension.

So anyway, I gave up my plans to try the 13" Ultimate on the dry sand, and since it's not rated waterproof I strapped on the SEF 12x10 and headed for the water. I would only be hunting a bit deeper than my knees due to not wanting to risk my control box mounted on the shaft, or even worse the meter which is mounted further down the shaft of course.

I hunted for a little while in discriminate and popped a necklace/pendant with a raised angel on the pendant. It looked white gold or perhaps silver in color. My heart rose when I saw the clasp was stamped 18K, but it sank when I saw it indicated plated after that. It had read as a zinc penny on my meter, since I was using my land shaft with the meter on it to see. This target was found in discriminate.

Little later I switched to PP mode to try hunting in that. Get a good "zing/zing" in PP mode, but it was hardly breaking thru a null in disc, even though it sounded only about 4 or 5" deep. Scoop up and I see a gold ring staring at me. Rest of the story on that in a minute.

Move on and PP says a big target, or at least wider than a coin/ring. Disc sounded real bad. Scoop. Shotgun shell. Scoop again. 1960 nickel. Scoop again. 1964 quarter, all of which was in same hole! I think there was iron in the hole as well judging by what PP was telling me, though I could never track that down.

Then I get a zing/zing again in PP mode. Switch to disc and it's a very super soft whisper that I could only hear in disc if I wiggled right on top of it. No way I would have heard it in disc just doing a general long hunting sweep. Scoop. Scoop. Scoop about 10 times. At about around a foot up comes a silver ring!

Then I hear another super deep zing/zing in PP mode. Once again disc would only report if I wiggled right over it. About 20 scoops chasing this thing and almost ready to give up when I no longer hear the signal in the water hole. Look in the scoop and I see a wide band gold ring! It had some black tarnish on it but I have seen gold come out of the water looking blackish before, so I wasn't going to decide until I read inside of the ring. 10k! But then the dreaded "GF" after it, meaning gold filled. Man, that one was super deep, and I have no doubt if I wasn't hunting in PP I would have never seen this one as well, because disc would only sound off if I was right on top of it wiggling.

Many of the targets in PP mode today would either null in disc no matter what angle, or hardly sound thru like an iron false, and yet turned out to be non-iron targets as little as say 5 or 6" deep or deeper on from there. Am I a PP mode believer? Sure am! At least at VERY mineralized beaches where microscopic iron, black sand, or minerals in general can choke a target down into the null range (iron), or try to ignore it like a ground signal. Would I hunt in PP when targets are numerous in disc? No, I would not. The BBS machines (Sov/Excal) are know for going where no other detector will in disc, but just the same even they have their limits in very badly mineralized soil or sand that would have other detectors limping at best. We stand above others in terms of depth in the worst of grounds, but even our machines can be put on their knees if the minerals, black sand, or microscopic iron is beyond belief for even our machines.

But if disc is only finding the light fluff stuff and no heavy stuff (coins, sinkers, gold rings, etc), and seems to be choking out on coins or tabs at say only 5 or 6" or so or deeper due to the ground matrix, and targets are scarce otherwise, then I'll for sure switch to PP and start seeing deeper thru the minerals/microscopic iron and see if heavier targets turn up, because that's the layer the gold is going to be laying at.

So getting back to the gold ring/karma thing. Turned out it was a 2013 high school graduation ring. Also turns out it had the name of the girl inside of it. I'm not going to lie to you. I was walking that edge of return to owner or scrap the rest of the day and on the drive home. This economy has been hard on me, so I'm not going to try to come off as a saint and say I found that ring and instantly knew it must go back to the owner. I walked that line for the rest of the day, convincing myself one way and then the other. In the end, on the drive home, I'll say I was 99% convinced to myself that times are hard and it's going to be scraped. But then I talked to a family member and they pushed me back to the other side of where I should have stood in the first place.

Long story short, fourth # I called in that city of the high school with that last name was the grandfather of the girl. He took my name/# and said the mother of the girl would be getting home shortly to confirm a few things about the ring/name/activity at the school it indicated the girl took part in. The mother called and it all matched up. Tomorrow after I do another beach hunt I'll be taking a short drive down the road from the beach to return it to her, and looks like I'll have a pic to share of either her or her daughter holding the ring.

The details of how the ring was lost? It said 2013 high school graduate on it, but the ring was bought last year, and only after about a month of having the ring the girl took a swim on the last day of school in June and lost it. The mother told me she had planned to buy her daughter another before she graduated next year, and without getting into specifics let's just say that I feel good about my choice. Not as good as I should because I hemmed and hawed over my moral decision before calling her, and in fact needed a family member on the phone on my ride home from the beach to push me back over to the moral side, so while I might sleep a tiny bit better tonight, I'd be sleeping a lot better had I not even wavered on the decision after I found the ring.

I ain't no saint, but my hypocrisy only goes so far I guess. After having my head handed to me and two other siblings in an large sum of inheritance money, the details of which I won't go into, let's just say that I've developed *slightly* better character then I had in my prior years of life, only because I don't want to be "that guy" that others look down for moral imperfections. At least then I can look to those I feel have done me wrong and not be so hypocritical when I think "I would have never have done to them what they did to me..."

Yea, I'm posting this, and I always thought to myself "If you've got the moral character to return a ring then why the need for self pride by posting the kind deed and pics of it?" Well, just so as to show you, as said, that my hyprocosy only goes so far, as this is the first ring when a name in it I've found that this delimia was ever presented to me, I'll only point out that I'm calling myself out here. I had FULLY intended by the end of the day, waging a moral war with my self, to scrap that ring. Only when I called a family member on the ride home did I get enough of a moral push to once again decide to do the right thing. So I'm not playing myself off as a saint here. I won't lie to you. I was well intending to scrap that ring and enjoy the money.

Sometimes you have to weigh your options a bit more and seek input before making any rash decisions. That said, had that family member not answered the phone, I would probably have drove straight to the local gold buy who gives me ARA prices (only 2% skimmed of the day's market price for gold) and cashed that puppy in. So I'm not the guy who wasn't fully intending to rob the bank, I'm just the guy who ended up changing his mind based on some obscure reason on the way there. :biggrin: So don't think otherwise... :nono:

Pictures of my finds by tomorrow, and hopefully a follow up story and pics of the ring returned to it's rightful owner...
 
I don't know you personally but from how you help people here on this forum. I really didn't think you had it in you to keep it. We all feel greedy when we find one... but then something comes over you and you end up doing the right thing. Good going for your own conscience.

Ron L
 
Thanks, I'll count you who see me on the "of help" side, but there are probably just as many who count me on the "great annoyance" side...:biggrin:
 
Good job Critter, It really takes a good person to do that..

I found a United States senators ring a few years ago, really had a hardtime with it..I talked to a friend about it, luck had it my friend Blisstool Barry new the gentleman. So I decided to have Barry asked the senator if he had lost his 21 gram 18k ring...Well the senator denied losing his ring, and said he had never been to VB ? ......Hate to say it, but man I was happy...So you did well...
 
Critter, lots of us love your posts and count you on the "of help" side..this is a good post, who woulda thought this hobby would bring most of us into the same dillema,... wrestling with the conscience regarding lost items found?...a very great excersize that everyone needs to undergo...unfortunately for us detectorists, the struggle always involves gold or plat! :clapping:
Mud
 
Nice find Critter !! and good return :thumbup: here is a story for all to read i know this guy who owns a metal detecting shop locally he has been in the buzz over 40 years and has one of the most INTENSE !!! collection of finds i have ever seen in displays in his shop most are water hunting finds he is a very early water hunter just as water machines first came out , i can only imagine what was found on beaches back then in the 60,s with no other hunters to really speak of ? , there is a large photo and news article of a ring he found at one of the boat basins out here with a very early PI water machine ,the ring is a large mans band 22k with a 5ct White Diamond surrounded by 6 Ruby's for a total of 8ct,s he kept the ring for a year after he told the press about it who posted the storey in the paper inside the ring was 2 letters and a date if the owner wanted it back all he had to do was tell Frank the date and 2 letters well 1 year past and no one ever claimed it , guess what ?? the date inside the band is 1919 and the ring was appraised at $124,000.00 !!! back then early 1960,s and he still has it never sold it .
I think he did his best to try and return it to the owner or family with a date that early 1919 ( what would most of you do ? ). By the way in his shop hanging on the ceiling is every metal detector ever made one day ill take a few photo,s .
Jim :detecting:
 
Critter,

That's a good story, and it points out what most of us go through at some time or another. Times might be hard for you, but that mother is not only feeding, clothing and educating her daughter, she purchased the ring to start with, and thought enough of it to purchase another if need be - you prevented them from hitting harder times due to a teenage error in judgment about swimming with her new ring. And the struggle with yourself that you described, well, it just shows that you are a human being, susceptible to the same temptations everyone else gets exposed to in their own area of "most likely to slip" or fall down in. Times will still be hard, but don't worry about the karma one way or the other. If you did the right thing, that's all that matters, and it will let you get a good nights sleep.
 
GREAT JOB CRITTER, YOU DID THE RIGH THING, REMEMBER WHAT GOES ARROUND CAMES ARROUND AND YOU WILL GET YOUR SHERE.
HH. ABEL
 
That was the right thing to do with the ring critter. When you have time, get us some pics. Sounds like some good stuff. Looks like you are really good at running in pp mode. Good luck in the future-Mark
 
Thanks to all who replied. Well, after another day of water hunting, I can say that after that the ring is with the rightful owner now. Before getting to that, I'll just give a quick update on my water hunt at the same beach today. I didn't hunt in PP mode, but rather (in the water as was yesterday) I thought I'd just cruise in discrimination mode and see what turns up. Yesterday I was using my land shaft with the remote PP switch wired into the grip, since I hadn't intended originally to water hunt. Today I chest mounted the GT on my water shaft (the stock shaft), and since it doesn't have a remote PP switch wired for the GT to plug into, I didn't feel like switching between both modes to check targets. Sure, chest mounted the stock switch is easy enough to get to, but the waves were so bad that I threw the control box on the back side of my neck to get it a little higher to insure no splashing on it, even though I had it sealed inside a zip lock bag before throwing it into the Minelab chest or hip mount bag.

So today first target was a toe ring. I was thinking white gold or silver but it was junk. Only other significant target was a 1943 silver war nickel. Rest of the day was a handful of coins and a bunch of junk. Was really missing my remote PP switch to hunt in PP and check in disc, which I could have done with the stock switch chest mounted near my upper left shoulder, but the waves were so bad I needed to throw it over my back left shoulder to raise it a bit more for added confidence against an accidental wave splash. Even though it was in a zip lock bag before sticking it in the Minelab bag, I hadn't secured the coil cable or head phone poke holes thru the bag with rubber bands or such to seal them, so I wasn't going to push my luck.

So onto the most important part...After my hunt I called the owner and said I was on my way. I was greeted by the mother I talked to last night, along with her daughter waiting for me in the driveway. After introductions, I got right to the point and handed the daughter the ring. She was very happy. She might have said "I thought I'd never see this again", but to be honest I'm not sure what she said due to the gravity of the situation, so I could be wrong. All I know is she was very happy, as was her mother.

The mother handed me a $50 reward. I won't go into the back and fourth of that, but just will say that I ended up keeping the $50 and let's leave it at that. Don't feel especially good about returning the ring, nor the $50, but only because I had that moral debate with myself before returning it when I should have stood on firm ground "to return" from the very start of finding that ring. I feel as if I should have known from the start of finding it to the very end of returning it what I had to do, so again I ain't no saint...I just talked to the right person on my way to cash that ring in that pushed me back to the other side of the moral war I was having with myself.

I'd like to tell you I got a picture of the girl or her mother with the ring, but I guess her father had decided he didn't feel comfortable with that and she informed me that the picture was no longer an option. I can't say I blame her, because truth be known if they had wanted to take a picture of me to post on the net or something I would have declined too. I'm funny about my voice or my picture being posted on the net. Heard to many horror stories of what has been done to people with that kind of personal information, so I in no way feel put off that her father told them he didn't want a picture taken.

So what I can offer you guys is a picture of the ring, which I'm going to post here in a minute along with my other finds from yesterday, but I'm going to review the picture first to make sure you can't read the school name or her name or anything. If you can then I'm going to blur out the words, because I don't wish to invade any body's privacy here. Hopefully a pic in a second.

PS- This is way off subject but in a small way sort of on subject, so I'm going to say it anyway...After a certain Uncle had passed away, and after I found out from a lawyer's letter that my two oldest siblings had not intentions to share a large fortune of an estate with me and my 2 other siblings when everybody had always said otherwise for years (them included), one day I came across my mother crying badly. I asked her what she was upset with, and she informed me that she had told my oldest sister (in charge of the estate) that she went over to my Uncle's house to retrieve a few gold jewelry items that my mom had loaned to his wife years ago, which were never returned, yet my mom never had the heart to ask her for them back. Well, my sister, when my mother told her what she did, tore into my mom and told her she had no right to do that because according to her (my sister)...All that was on that property was property of the estate.

Let me tell you folks, my mom is a church going finest Christian you ever met in your entire life. For my sister to so much accuse her of somehow stealing from some estate shows just how much greed and money can poison a person's mind. My sister counts herself as a "proud" "every Sunday" church goer. While I'll never claim to be of that "class", I'd like to think I've got enough common sense not to let greed get to my head and start accusing my own mother of somehow "stealing" from an estate. So in many ways that thought kept going through my mind yesterday, as I weighed the moral decision of returning that ring or not, because I don't want somebody looking down on me as some kind of money grubbing gold ring slug who is so petty that I'd b*tch over a few hundred dollars in scrap gold weight while I know very well I'm planning to take the rest and run with it.

You can call me a lot of things, and in my prior days you'd more than likely be right, but at least at this point in time, what I can at least say...Is that I'm *slightly* more ruled by my conscience then I was before...
 
Critter,
I'm sure when you hand the ring back there will be a lot of good feelings about the choice made. Hope you soon find a good piece of gold with no identifying markings.

With respect to OBN's "Well the senator denied losing his ring, and said he had never been to VB" Wouldn't you like to know the rest of the story? I'm sure the Senator knows a lot more about the situation that isn't being said! At least something that was paid for by tax payers was returned to a tax payer; by way of the work and effort put into finding the ring!
Cheers,
tvr
 
OK, got the pic. I reviewed it to make sure the name of the school and such is not readable, because I'm trying to keep this thing private of course in terms of the rightful owner...
 
Nice !!! Question when your hunting in pp with the sovereign gt on the wet sand is your threshold sooth or is it a little erratic ....what are your settings? I tried pp today at a fl beach and it was pretty sharp. You have to understand what you are listening for...it another ball game altogether.

I had volume about 2pm Sens. right out of auto and the thres. low. but it never was smooth ????

Ron L
 
What you see here is my finds from yesterday. From right to left, a 18K (but plated) necklace/pendant with a raised angel on it, a 1964 silver Washington quarter, a silver ring, and then last two items below those from right to left...A 10K (It was marked K something, At least 10K) PLATED broad band man's ring, and then finally and most importantly the 2013 high school graduate ring. I'm glad the picture is blurred, because it saves me the trouble of blurring out and names and such on the right. The ring is 10K and has a pink stone.

PP mode worked for me, because on this badly mineralized beach (and in the water where I found this stuff), targets about 5 to 6" or deeper were choking out on either the microscopic iron, the black sand, or just the minerals in general. PP mode would often "zing/zing" on a good hit, where as when I flipped over to discriminate they would either only sound off if I wiggled right on top of them (which I most likely would have missed had not PP told me to wiggle over them in disc), or they would null one way, or they would so hardly break through that you'd bet money they were iron or say a bobby pin or some other junk.

So just saying, if you think a beach is "dead", try hunting in PP. Even on a fresh water beach where iron doesn't rot as fast, don't think that you are going to dig iron all day. Often I knew a target was iron by how PP would act. Fuzzy on the approach or decline before/past the target, or the other thing I notice is only a one way "zing" in PP while sweeping back is silent or near that. Those always (so it seems) both turn out to be iron. I'm still learning the rich language of PP, and I hear all metal on the GT (a different form of all metal than the PP all metal mode which lacks a ground balance) also has a rich unique language to it, so don't even think you have to switch back to disc to see what is up. Sure, it's nice to do with a remote PP switch, but just the same you don't really need to switch to disc to decide. If PP tells me it's "fuzzy" at the edges, or only sounds off one direction, then it's always iron at least thus far. I only switch to disc just to see things while I learn what PP is telling me, but if it's silent in disc and yet PP tells me it sounds say 5" or deeper (for this beach), then I'm digging...Just because that's the whole point on this bad beach...That PP will see things disc is having major issues with.

Also, as bad as disc sounds for the GT on this beach, just remember that our BBS machines stand above others in terms of handling the worst of minerals, black sand, or microscopic iron in soils or sands. So before you get frustrated, just remember if your Excal or GT is having issues in disc, imagine what other machines are only able to do at such a site, on land or in the sand.
 
According to what I think I've read from OldBeechNut so far, in PP mode you cank put sensitivity full blast. I haven't done that yet though. I just set sensitivity to the normal stability for disc, but he makes a good point...If you switch to disc with sensitivity at full, even if it's highly unstable, you are only doing that for a sec to hear the tone ID so it's not a huge issue to have sensitivity at full for the few secs in disc.

Far as the threshold in PP, it's smooth as butter. I only hear it change when I zing by a target. If yours is unstable I suspect EMI interference, because I can't say yet once (anywhere I've used PP) that it was unstable on me. It's very essense is stability.

Far as volume, I may be wrong but in my recent youtube video PP at lowest volume got like (from memory 4" less depth then PP at full volume). I'm still running at lowest volume only because my headphones don't have volume controls, but just the same at this beach max depth for PP is not an issue, because even at 5 or 6" deep at least sometimes disc is choking or nulling all together while PP is sounding off just fine. From my tests though, volume lowest or highest on my Gt shows no change (thus far) in disc depth (refer to Youtube video), but PP mode lowest volume got 2" less depth than disc and 2" more than disc when at highest volume. Now, those were air tests, so even with volume at lowest on this beach PP is obviously seeing targets disc can't see. It's not a "depth" issue, but rather an "ability to see" issue. But just the same, if you want max depth in PP, so far it looks like max volume and all the way up sensitivity. I just have so many targets at moderate depth PP can see that disc can't that I don't need to push those extremes, yet...
 
Is there a disadvantage or should I not use PP on my GT if my beach isn't Mineralized ??? Everyone seems to be talking about Mineralized beaches
 
According to some, PP mode at full volume will still see deeper than discrimination in even mild soils or sands. My recent video test I posted does seem to prove that theory, but I'm doing more tests to see.

I've heard some say in the past that PP mode at full volume gives them the depth of at least *some* PI units they've used. Not sure which ones or if that is indeed true or not, but I have read some say that. But just the same, just don't forget that even discrimination on the BBS machines is known for extreme depth among VLF units.

One thing I'd say lends creditbility to the PP mode depth is that some heavy hitter Excal users have wired an audio amp to them so they can hear what the threshold in PP is doing even better, and seems to look like it gives them even more depth from what little I've read. Probably OBN can chime in on that because I think (?) he's one who uses an audio amp on his Excal. I might be mistaken, but didn't he just post about that and that for some odd reason the Sovereign showed no gain in depth by amping the audio in PP mode because it seemed to do it on it's own without need of the audio amp? I need to re-read that message and see if that was what he was saying, because I might have that wrong.

Just the same, remember too that this PP mode stuff, or especially the audio amp thing, is probably being used by those who are hunting hard hit beaches with lots of competition where to find stuff they need every edge in depth. If targets are numerous I wouldn't use PP mode. I didn't today water hunting because the beach had a lot of targets laying around in the water even at this mineralized beach, but if I hadn't thrown my chest mounted control box on my back shoulder to give me more insurance against the wave action I probably would have ran PP instead of disc.
 
The silver ring and the angel pendant have also found new homes now. I've offered my neighbor a few rings over the years if she liked them but she either never saw one she liked or the ones she did like wouldn't fit her finger. So yesterday I was over there showing off some of my finds. Never even thought to ask her if she liked that silver ring because of all the bad luck with that before. :biggrin:

Anyway, next thing I know she's got the silver ring on her finger and says "I really like this thing and it fits my finger." Shocked she finally had luck with one that fit and she liked so I told her it was hers to keep. She wanted to know what I wanted for it and I told her if I sit here and drink 5 or 6 of your beers we'll call it even. She agreed, as sharing a few beers is a favorite pass time of ours while making conversation :beers:

As for the angel pendent, she has a bulletin board in her kitchen with a bunch of little angels thumb tacked onto it from like key chains and such, so I told her now she's got another to stick up there for luck. Took a while to convince her 18K plated has no value to it so I didn't want anything for that, but after debating that back and fourth over the course of drinking a few I think I finally won that argument. :biggrin: The pendant looks old. The pic doesn't show it well but the angel is raised off of it as a separate piece of metal work. Really pretty little thing. Just too bad it's only plated.
 
Top