Coin tumbling question…

[KSDfisher77]

I use stainless steel pins & a rotary tumbler with 2 drops of dawn ultra dish soap & a 9mm case full of Lemi-Shine. Tumble the pennies separately.

 

[Picketwire]

Tumble the pennies separately.

I found out early! I was horrified at all the pink clad.

 

[Mike Moutray - St.Louis MO]

This has been bugging me for years and have never been able to find a good answer
Tumbled some clad today and as usual
They came out like this (red patina)
No coppers mixed in
I know it spends but am curious if any one found a way for them not to come out like this.
Aquarium gravel and pine sol used today

I always tumbled the clad with sand and nothing else for 3 hours... plenty of water. I then emptied water and added a couple tablespoons of aluminum jelly and tumbled for a few minutes more. Rinse thoroughly under COLD water and dry right away. Exposure to air or heat when wet turns them red again, so dry them right away. This works with turning your old nickels grey again. Take care
Mike.

 

[robo]

Thanks all
Some great responses

 

[Donna(NJ]

This has been bugging me for years and have never been able to find a good answer
Tumbled some clad today and as usual
They came out like this (red patina)
No coppers mixed in
I know it spends but am curious if any one found a way for them not to come out like this.
Aquarium gravel and pine sol used today

I was doing s batch of clad quarters and they came out PINK !!! I checked the batch and no pennies. I used vinegar & salt way back when. Then to shine things up, I used lime juice.
Usually worked well with removing the pink. On one occasion nothing would remove the pink. Turned out one side of the clad quarter had split off and there was the copper core turning everything pink. Try the lime juice in water and run over night. Im using stainless steel shot nowadays and everything comes out shiny and new. May have to do a few runs to get the red to lighten up. Also, a squirt of Lime-a-way in water is my new 'go to' cleaner for coins. Give it a try.

HH
Donna(NJ)

 

[Ray(Ca)]

A cup of sand, couple ounces of lemon ammonia and water up to the level of the coins. In a 3 lb tumbler for 8 hours. Coins come out fine. Been doing it this way for 30 years.
Ray

 

[Waterdog]

I always use

1/8" Stainless Steel Ballcone Tumbling Media Shot Jewelers Tumbler Finishing , vinegar to the top of the coins and a dash of salt. Tumble for 45 minutes to a hour and the red or pink is gone Yeah​

 

[Mark kus]

I use stainless steel pins & a rotary tumbler with 2 drops of dawn ultra dish soap & a 9mm case full of Lemi-Shine. Tumble the pennies separately.

Stainless shot of mixed styles from ebay and water and a little CLR
Mark