Herb,
Well you're question is a tough one..with a ton of variables. I wouldn't claim to have the absolute best answer..
Here are some thoughts that may help you..
Generally, if you do not have much info as to the history of any givin place,
I go with my instincts first. Then try n think of what activities may have taken place with the old homestead.
I have good luck with the driveway.....or trail...ie wagon...ect..n see if you can home in on where the people loaded and unloaded
From\to a carriage? Horse...or wagon?? ...alot of times items can be found here.
Is there a well somewhere on the place? Check the to and from the house here.
Kids love trees! Then.... And now.... Any large trees or leftover signs of large trees around??
Definitely check around them all!
Try an imaginary radius of about thirty or so feet from the main house\ foundation..
Sometimes I have had great results from roughly this radius...outward...it all depends...
Give those ideas a try..... N see what you might find.
The yard probably has had alot of different activities since the 1840's
So persistence. Will pay off
Remember ....go with your gut feelings.......it has definitely paid off for me in the past while hunting places just like what you are lucky enough to get to..
Maybe some of this will help you look at the place in some different views?
Good luck and just because one day was a blow out....doen't necessarily mean
There isn't anything there for you to find....keep going!!!
HH
HaloEffect426.