If you suspect it could be a valuable coin --- it is worth soaking in Hydrogen Peroxide 3%.
That is the same Hydrogen Peroxide you purchase at the grocery or drug store.
Take a look at this link that shows how a crusty disc became a nice 1877 Japanese coin after a few weeks of soak and scrub - soak and scrub - soak and scrub.
I was very careful not to get agressive with the scrubbing until I was sure how much crud VS how much coin would be scrubbed away.
http://www.findmall.com/read.php?18,939819,941897#msg-941897
Of, course the type of metal surely effects how all this works as well.
Here is another link from a coin site that talks about coin cleaning, and different methods; including hydrogen peroxide.
http://www.coincommunity.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=99361&SearchTerms=cleaning,hydrogen,peroxide
http://www.coincommunity.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=101485&SearchTerms=peroxide
I am curious to learn more because I have some really crudded up old Indian Head cents that I would like to know the dates on.
I also have a decent (if I can remove the encrustation) 1872 IH cent that will be worth a lot more unencumbered
I am going to experiment a bit when I get the cash with some of the commercially available coin cleaners i.e. "verdi-clean", and others.
I will also try to do some cleaning with acetone on some of my crusty leftovers to see what happens.
NEVER NEVER NEVER will I even consider any of these treatments for my 1891s Seated Liberty Quarter.
So the original value/rarity of the coin counts in making the right decision.
But, what if you cannot even tell what the coin is without some heavy-duty cleaning?
nwdetectorist
TOO MUCH DIRT, NOT ENUFF TIME!