Find's Treasure Forums

Welcome to Find's Treasure Forums, Guests!

You are viewing this forums as a guest which limits you to read only status.

Only registered members may post stories, questions, classifieds, reply to other posts, contact other members using built in messaging and use many other features found on these forums.

Why not register and join us today? It's free! (We don't share your email addresses with anyone.) We keep email addresses of our users to protect them and others from bad people posting things they shouldn't.

Click here to register!



Need Support Help?

Cannot log in?, click here to have new password emailed to you

Changed email? Forgot to update your account with new email address? Need assistance with something else?, click here to go to Find's Support Form and fill out the form.

Video: Garrett ATX vs Minelab GPX 5000 - PART II - :starwars:

bearkat4160

New member
Heres some very interesting test results regarding the ATX vs GPX w stock DD coils, check it out...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxvQ0kcfUmo

Here is a direct link to Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxvQ0kcfUmo
 
Ouch.

Waiting for the big deep nugget test and the ML mono coil,comparison, but for North America, the outlook for $5k detectors seems to be partly cloudy at the moment.

Thanks for your work. As data accumulates, conclusions will begin to be drawn.
 
Great video bearkat4160, thanks for posting it.

Just a heads up here BK with the Minelab owners. They are a "master" of diverting and side tracking people that do these comparisons to move over to their turf ("mono") to make the results look better (which may or may not be the case here).

I think the point may be missed on how Garrett is presenting the ATX package to the public on a DD platform that can pick up small gold right out of the box not a Mono platform which some of the Minelab owners are trying so hard for you to do (on your youtube site).

It's entirely up to you on how you make these "great" video comparisons BK, I just wanted to give you a heads up on what I see transpiring on your you tube site that's all.

Thanks for your hard work BK great job and I hope you continue to make more.

:)
 
Lol, I'll think about it...
 
A man always needs a good backup.

I will tell ya this...I've not had a chance to look at the ATX in person yet. But I've owned the Infinium, TDI, TDI Pro, GPX 4500 & 5000. I was honestly surprised in the lack of sensitivity to smaller gold; 1 gram and smaller especially. My 5000 came with both the 11" mono and DD coil though...but I relic & coin hunt...don't gold prospect with detectors. I did play with the mono coil while I had it and I still wasn't impressed with the super fine gold ability of the 5000. I do gold prospect; mostly with a dredge or sluice box. Our gold is very small...if you find a half gram picker here, you done extremely well. Where the pulse machines come into play for me, is the ability to see through this harsh red "iron dirt" we have here. Since this is a gold bearing area, we have the highly mineralized soil that comes with it...except the stuff I choose to hunt are mostly relics.

You might have covered this in a previous video, but I have a question regarding the discrimination and or iron check. Are those two different features, or one in the same? I tried to watch your video of the discrimination capabilities of the ATX, but I have a slow connection and the video kept starting and stopping so I couldn't watch it all. What I did see, is that running the discrimination on it, lowered the depth quite a bit on the objects I saw. If the iron check feature is different...that would mean a person could run the discrimination @ nearly nothing, and then just use the iron check to break the signal up if its iron. If that's the case, I would almost buy one tomorrow. I can't afford a GPX again but I liked the iron breakup it does with the DD coils on iron.
 
Great job! I love seeing the hype kicked in the nads.
I use a gpextreme with a large coil for deeper medium nuggets & still finding small gold & black sand the the GMT.

This video sells the Garrett! Too much kungfu to get the minelab to perform.

Thanx again for realest video instead of an apologist one with hype.

Kenny
 
Is it safe to say pictures speak loader than words? Great video comparison. Thank you bearkat4160
 
You are welcome Kenny!
 
Yes Dan the 5000 a bit over rated, well to me anyway, but I have one and it has it's purpose with me regarding prospecting. Regarding the ground your in, in the South...well I know it well as I'm from Georgia and have found gold with my detectors there as well as many many pounds of civil war relics every since me and my brother were in high school when we started detecting. A PI can indeed help in that hot red clay, I miss the way it smells though...dirt smells different out here in Oregon.

About the disc and iron chk...they are different. The discrimination is basically the same as on the Infinium and can work just like the reverse discrimination on the infinium. The iron check is a whole separate circuit and only works with the 12" DD coil. Very good for relics like when I'm hunting for gold, what else do you find hunting for gold?...well relics or crap which can be one in the same...Lol

Bearkat
 
That is a GREAT video.
Doesn't the GPX have a DD coil? The one on it
looks like a mono coil. Would not the GPX have done better
with a DD like the ATX?
Hope someone makes a video comparing the TDI with ATX.
Robt2300
 
I have just completed a new video with the GPX with a mono coil vs ATX DD's. I went through as many relevent timings and settings as possible on camera to give the GPX a better shot that just flipping one switch and one timing.
Interesting results that will be online in a day or so...also did a test on a buried 5.4 oz gold nugget...that was cool. Minelab got it at max 23" and the ATX at 20". Video will show this soon... There's your extra $3300 for the GPX working for ya!

Is it worth it? I report, you decide...Lol

BK
 
Top