Find's Treasure Forums

Welcome to Find's Treasure Forums, Guests!

You are viewing this forums as a guest which limits you to read only status.

Only registered members may post stories, questions, classifieds, reply to other posts, contact other members using built in messaging and use many other features found on these forums.

Why not register and join us today? It's free! (We don't share your email addresses with anyone.) We keep email addresses of our users to protect them and others from bad people posting things they shouldn't.

Click here to register!



Need Support Help?

Cannot log in?, click here to have new password emailed to you

Changed email? Forgot to update your account with new email address? Need assistance with something else?, click here to go to Find's Support Form and fill out the form.

This Might Be My Most Expensive Coin Yet! :thumbup:

Critterhunter

New member
OK, I'm excited! Up until today this year has been a bust for me, with only one rosie and a bunch of wheats, but no other good finds to speak of until today. But, in my defense, I haven't been hunting as often or with the vigor that I usually do this time of year. Some of you might remember a few months back that I took two friends with two very good detectors to a house lot around the corner from me less than a mile away. That day I was not feeling well, so I mostly watched them hunt. They came back the next day and finished gridding out this lot that had one of the older houses in the area on it that they tore down over the winter.

Anyway, the total they ended up with after finishing gridding this place was a few rosies and mercs, a seated dime, 7 to 9 indians, and many wheats. The one guy also got a worn (no date) standing liberty quarter. The front yard of this site is divided into three small areas of grass by two driveways, with all three patches maybe 50 to 70 feet wide and a little longer, so the area suits it's self well to gridding well without getting sloppy and missing rows.

So, my one friend that gridded this particular center patch of grass between the two driveways that I decided to work today was digging any and all coin signals from zinc penny on up, and that's why he got a bunch of indians out of there as well as the other coins, including 3 indians in one hole. He's a good hunter and maticulous about his grid patterns, so I figured this would be a good challenge to see if the old Sovereign GT could pull any stuff he missed out of there. (EDIT: I have since been told by him that he didn't grid this particular patch of grass as tightly as he normaly does, which explains the numerous copper memorials I was finding that he must have missed along with other clads. I knew he was better than that....But I think what helped me was I went VERY slow and only advanced the coil by inches at a time, not to mention that I too have a very good machine.)

I started my grid off and right away dug a few copper non-wheat pennies out of one hole. "You missed that one bud...", I thought to myself. A good sign, as they were only a few inches deep. My plan was to dig any and all signals above iron as this yard, like many yards, wasn't all that trashy, and I've had good luck digging rings in yards because the ring to trash ratio is usually pretty good, and people have had years doing yard work or playing in the yard to potentially lose a ring. Besides, this place is old enough for a gold coin or some other odd old coin that reads lower on the scale. I decided that as long as the signal was good and locked on to one or two numbers, and didn't bounce around or sound sick, then I was digging anything from foil on up as rings usually lock into one or two numbers.

The only sick sounding or iffy changing stuff I was going to dig was any coin signals, because obviously there probably wasn't going to be much junk in this yard to give false coin hits, so any bad sounding or one way ones could be a coin on edge or masked or something. But, as said, from foil up to just under coppy penny, I wanted a good locked on solid hit to avoid any can shards or other aluminum and such junk that usually will change by 3 digits or more. That was my game plan, so I probably in total only passed up maybe 5 to 10 signals or so that were below copper penny and junky sounding or with a jumpy ID in total.

So an hour to an hour and a half goes by and I'm taking it real slow and nice and easy, and thus far I've got an apron full of about 14 copper non-wheat pennies, 1 wheat, around 8 zincs, 5 or 6 pulltabs, and a few other assorted bits of junk. Along with that, probably about 4 or 5 clad dimes and a couple clad quarters. Obviously he didn't get everything here, despite how good and tight he grids and he does go slow with his machine like he should. (EDIT: Again, I since found out from him that he was a bit sloppy gridding this particular patch of grass and not up to his usual standards.) I think the difference was I took it real slow, and tried to follow my new found religion to go even slower with coil advancement then I normaly go. A few inches at a time advancing, and keeping the coil just in front of my feet. I knew I'd need to go slow like this to find the stuff he missed, because he's got a very good machine that's equal to mine in finding old coins and he's the best hunter I personaly know.

Anyway, sorry for the big build up. An hour and a half or so after I started I'm still not done with this small patch of grass in the center of the lot between the two driveways, but I'm starting to get sloppy so I figure one more row and I'll pick up where I left out tomorrow, as there was a tree in this row to mark where I left off. I get to the end of the row and am about 5 feet from the sidewalk when I get an instant and perfect 180 signal. "OK", I thought..."Got to be at least a clad quarter or perhaps a silver dime or such because I noticed they tend to jump to 180 more instantly while copper pennies can linger in the 178 or 179 area and clad dimes are a bit slower to make it to 180 than a clad quarter or a silver dime or quarter."

I dig the hole, stick in my Pro Pointer, find the target, and flip out a bit more dirt at the bottom of the hole at a depth of about 5" or so. Instantly I see a silver quarter's back! Either a barber or a standing liberty, I think to myself, as the back of those are either the same (?) or look the same to me from memory, so it's either or. Pick the coin up, flip it over, and it's a 1921 Standing Liberty Quarter! Instantly I see there is just a little tiny bit of wear on it! No mint mark. Hmmmm....I think, this could be a good chunk of change, as the early standing liberty quarters wore badly and fast, and normaly didn't have a date, as the lady and the date were raised and they say would wear off in a year or so! Later they re-designed them so the date and stuff was recessed so they didn't wear as fast, but I knew a 1921 was one of the ones that wear fast.

This is only might 5 to 7th standing liberty quarter from memory, and I think either one of the others had any date, or maybe I could just hardly read the date on one. Can't remember. Anyway, I decided it's time to quit because I'm getting sloppy and pick up tomorrow. Besides, I wanted to check the book to see just what kind of value I have here. GET READY FOR THIS!

Only one coin type for 1921, and that's one with no mint mark. I look down the grades for it and my heart starts going....This book was published in 2010, so I'm sure these prices are even higher than what I'm about to list! G-4 $177. V-G8 $210. F-12 $425. VF-20 $650. EF-40 $750.

I read the grading guide to see what it might be. The shield still has fine detail on the rim pattern that goes around the edge. It's not just a line outlining the rim, but rather these rims have some kind of pattern on them. It looks unworn there. The center of the shield still has some line detail to what's there, but it's a bit warn. The lines in her dress are still pretty darn crisp too.

According to the book I know this coin is easily and conservately a G-4. But I'm pretty sure it is at least either a V-G8 or a F-12, and *possibly* even a higher grade then that! I've got to put my scope on her to really see for sure, but by the eye I'm guessing V-G8 or F-12 if not higher, but a sure bet this baby is at least G-4 by the naked eye!

Now, thus far my two other most expensive coins were a seated quarter that looked in uncirculated condition but had a couple of nasty dings in the edge (they weren't shiney so I didn't do them digging I don't think). If it wasn't for those dings that coins was like $1350. The other good coin was a silver 3 cent piece that was I think about a $190 coin from memory, as it also had no visible wear. Anyway, depending on where that seated quarter would have sold for this standing liberty might be my most expensive coin!

Unfortunately I don't have a very close up focus camera, and it uses a compact flash card that the computer I use now doesn't have a port for, but I'll try to get ahold of either an adaptor or somebody elses camera to post a picture for you guys.

Needless to say I'm pumped and going back tomorrow. After this small patch of grass is done I've got two other blocks of grass in the front yard and then a big back yard to hunt, so this might be a two week type of deal. My two friends with great machines like mine are good hunters, but obviously they didn't get it all! Not to mention the guy with a 90's detector that showed up and hunted this spot while they were there one day. :smoke:

Update: I'll let you know what the dealer offers me for it and how he grades it. I gave it a gentle cleaning with some dish washing soap and warm water and looked under a loop. From what I see it's either V-G8 at $210 or F-12 at $425. These are retail prices from a 2010 book, so I bet those prices are a bit higher today. It's easily G-4 $177 without a doubt, but I feel according to the grade guide it's either VG-8 or F-12.

I'll keep you guys updated on my future hunts at this site as I continue to grid it out.

By the way, I talked to my friend who gridded that center patch of grass and he said he was a bit sloppy by then because he had been hunting the site extensively already that day. I know how that goes, and that explains all the copper memorials and other coins I dug because I didn't think he would normaly miss that many coins in such a small area. He's better than that. But, either way, I think what made the difference was that I crawled along only inching the coil forward by inches at a time. I'll tell you guys how well I do at the next block of grass on the other side of the driveway, because I think he said he gridded that one more intensely. Should be a good challenge to see how I and the GT can find what he missed at that spot. The key is going super slow and not getting in a hurry.
 
I am out of work at the moment so I did the unthinkable to some of you and decided I'd see what the local dealer would give me for this coin. He's been pretty good to me in the past for gold prices and the times-face-value amount on common silver coins. That is, for a local walk in shop he is pretty fair, as I know you can get more for scrap gold and such via some large refinaries via mailing it in, but he beats the price of all the other local walk in shops in my area by a good bit.

So I did some surfing on Ebay comparing pictures to my coin and found a few that pretty much match the condition it was in. So here you go...

The prices on these coins on there compariable condition wise to it were in roughly the F-12 grade (the high end of what I thought it's grade was, so I'm happy with that) and were around the $500 range and more, but obviously those are asking prices with no bids on them at all that I saw as that's full blown retail. I took it up to a dealer and he offered me $150 for it. I questioned the price and he started to turn his computer screen my way to show me where he can get that year and grade for just over $200 from his sources, so I was pretty confident that he was straight up about that with me and said no need.

Hey, for found money digging one target I'm happy as pie with $150 walking out the door. Filled my truck up and now I can buy a 6 pack of some premium beer (premium beer to me is something like Budweiser, instead of Natural Light :biggrin: ) to celebrate tonight. :beers:

Mine might have slightly more wear than these at the very center of the shield, but the date on mine looks raised more than these do, so it's roughly about the grade of these two coins, and confirms the F-12 condition he gave me.

I realize that to some of you guys selling your silver is sacrilege but hey, I'm out of work at the moment and I've got pictures of coins in similar condition ight here posted below that I can cut out and stick in my collection. Actually that's not a bad idea...:biggrin: When times aren't as rough for me I'll of course hold onto my silver again, as I always do with my bronze or copper coins because of course most of those are pretty much not worth enough to be worth selling.
 
A bit long-winded but . . congratulations !!! :clap:
 
Thanks. Yes, long winded for sure but I'm the type who loves to read detailed stories and not just the typical "look what I found" stuff without hearing all the gory details. Besides, I'm a fast typer so it only took a few minutes to write that admittedly long post. Thanks again.
 
Funny you should say that Critter, I always figured you to be "lightning" on the keyboard. Your posts would take me a day and a half to type....I enjoy them though....
 
I sell everything I find I'm not collecting anything at my age (6:geek:. GOLD SILVER OLD COINS. I WEIGH AND TEST ALL MY GOLD AND USE EBAY TO SELL MOST FOR TOP DOLLARS. But don't forget after ebay's super fees you might be better off selling local. But I get near double most of the time.
 
CRITT THAT IS ABSOLULTY A BEUTIFULL COIN, WOW LOOK AT THE CONDITION ITS IN , MOST ARE SO WORN OUT YOU CANT READ THE DATE amazing find must have been droped not long after minting , whooo
 
FINE AT LEAST BRO ,
 
Thanks again everybody who bothered to read my long post. It was for sure in the top 3 in terms of the most expensive coins I've ever found. One of my detecting friends who used to work at a coin shop told me he would have given me $200 to $250 for that coin just to keep in his collection. Never even crossed my mind to run it by him before taking it to the local dealer. Next time I'll know better and not jump the gun so fast. I'll at least check the sold section on fleabay to see what something has been selling for, as I never knew you could do that until my friend told me how the other day via their advanced search menu. Either way, not going to cry over not getting every single penny out of a great find. Never look a gift horse in the mouth.

Besides, my beloved female long haired husky passed away last night at the vet due to kidney failure. She was in her prime so I never expected that. Puts things into perspective as far as money not being all that important in life. Love the ones your with, human and dog. The money will take care of it's self.
 
Sorry about your pup, CH. We know what your feeling.
 
Sorry about your loved one. They pass 7 times too fast! Also second guessing can make life almost as miserable so right on with that.
Big point is what you find is yours to do with as you please. If you need or want to sell it is your choice. BUT a word from vicarious experience... never sell on one appraisal unless you totally have to or are dead SURE you are getting a crazy good price. I have heard a ton of regret stories and some are sadder than a chick flick.
Just sayin...
Tom
PS You got me beat ten way to Tuesday with your finds! Congrats and HH!
 
Thanks for the kind words of support about my dog. I never met a soul as special as hers, human or not. I'd gladly give back all the silver coins I've ever found even to have one more day with that dog. Thanks again.
 
Critterhunter said:
Thanks. Yes, long winded for sure but I'm the type who loves to read detailed stories and not just the typical "look what I found" stuff without hearing all the gory details. Besides, I'm a fast typer so it only took a few minutes to write that admittedly long post. Thanks again.
....

When a person is out of work he can be as long winded as he wants...
 
Top