Sunray X-5 vs Joey

[RussC]

Can anyone here give me a first hand experience account of how these coils compare to one another? I`m finding that the areas I`ve hunted are loaded with trash(parks and picnic areas) and nails and assorted other ferrous junk around the old homesteads.

Thanks, Russ

 

[Rick(ND)]

I find if it is solid nails and other trash than the 5 inch is the only way to go as it has excellent seperation of target. Now if it is moderate trash than the Joey is the coil I use as it seperate much better than the stock coil as it gets into tight spots, feels good on the end of the shaft as it is not so heavy. I have found a few area where there is so much trash I have to use a 5 inch coil. They both have their place, the Joey gets better depth and better coverage, but the 5 inch will get into the trash and pick out the good targets.

 

[NealNoINIronBrigade]

Just realize that a 5 inch coil REALLY limits your depth. I've used both and I can see where the X-5 will come in handy in a super, super trashy spot. But the Joey coil is what I would recommend for most trashy sites. I know it happens, but there aren't very many good old coins in the 3-5 inch depth range and thats about all you're going to get with the X-5, maybe 6 inches if the ground is real clean. But who would use a 5 inch coil if the ground is real clean?
Neal