- - in fact if you can get a good price, run, don't walk, to get it.
To date, I have tried the Fisher 1280X, the Detector Pro models, the White's BHID and the Tiger Shark in fresh water.
- I rank the TS at the front of that pack, Numero Uno.
- I like the 1280X a lot and consider it a close second. Between these two, it is hard not to choose Fisher's Aquanaut.
- The Whites BHID was nice, and I liked it but for one thing - the one I used was equipped with a floating coil! Not at all good.
Get one with the neutral buoyancy coil and it ranks third in my book.
- The Detector Pro's didn't impress me and in truth, they are a license built Fisher "X series" circuit, anyway. I found the audio to be weak and while the concept is intriguing, the whole thing taken together wasn't robust enough to suit me.
The only
other detector I would consider a good choice in fresh water is Fisher's CZ-20/21. But at more than twice the cost of these others, it isn't one I recommend for everyone. It offers the multi-frequency VLF option for salt water, though, so it may be a good choice for those who visit the seashore often enough. Ditto Minelabs Excalibur, which has a good record in the salt. However, many people swear their Excal swings like a brick without a special support harness. That don't sound so good, if you know what I mean...
Why not a PI? No reliable iron discrimination, that's why. Only Garrett's Infinium has made any strides towards that end, and it is hardly refined. It is also over $1,000USD, new.
In fresh water, iron discrimination is a major boon and easily possible with existing VLF technology - so it is an aid not to be lightly tossed aside.
Enter the Tiger Shark. It is essentially a waterproof Bandido, so it is sensitive, stable and offers good iron DISC. It also has a manual GB. The major controls, SENS, THRESH and VOL are inside the case, so they cannot be bumped out of whack. You set them for your locale and then forget them. I would prefer the first two be front-face adjustable, but I can live with it.
After all, in the water you have enough to do. Between hanging on to your scoop, keeping your footing and watching your float basket - not to mention the eye candy - having "set and forget" controls is a good thing.
NOTE: Be careful with the SENS. You can easily get it out of whack by cranking it up.... don't ask me how I know. And because it is inside the case, it is a major pain in the a$$ to adjust.
Therefore, any changes to factory SENS settings should be approached with caution. I recommend you leave it alone at first.
I DO recommend you bump the THRESH a little to sharpen up responses and turn the volume up near max.
Tesoros 'Shark is also built like a tank. Make sure the seal is clean so it seals well and you can pretty much forget about it. I prefer it below the hand in the standard rod mount position. I've tried it all ways and find it floats neutral in that spot.
I hate body mounting and the cuff position is awkward to me.
The Tiger Shark also offers interchangeable coils, something few others can match. Two sizes are all you need: 8" and 10."
IF I couldn't have my Tiger Shark, I'd have a 1280X. BUt that is not a choice I have to make at present. Get the TS. You'll like it.