I generally run my GTI-2500 in all metal mode unless the ground is really trashy. My sensitivity is pretty much at 7 and I leave it there. I am very satisfied with the depth I get with the detector, finding a dime at 5-6 inches is not a problem and I'll get more depth if the soil and moisture is right. I will often hit a target in all metal and switch to coin or relic and confirm the target in that mode---if it is a good target I'll get that sweet tone, but even targets with the not-so-sweet tone that still sound solid and size right I'll dig. With my 2500 I have learned several important realities--and comparing with other GTI-2500 owners have confirmed that each machine behaves different, you really have to become acquainted with it. One reality is that image, identity and depth are rarely what the screen tells you. On MY 2500 the depth is almost always less than what the meter reads. It will say the target is 5 inches down and I'll find it at 3 inches. It will identify the target in the coin range and it will be iron or vice versa. I find especially in ferrous soil I will get a reading on the meter that the target is in the nickel-pull tab area. If I remove a few inches of soil over the target and re-sweep the target will now show in the coin zone--or vice versa. The one area that my detector is very accurate on is the size. If it says it is coin size the target may not be a coin, but it will be the size of one. If every indicator on the 2500 says the target is a coin--right tone, right depth, right zone on the meter---but the size does not indicate coin, it is never a coin. Conversely, if the tone says coin and the zone says coin and the size says coin, it is a coin 90% of the time. I've sent my detector to Garrett for a full tune up and got it back with a clean bill of health. The reality is, work the machine and get to understand what it is telling you. I listen to the sounds in my headphone and use the meter to confirm whether I will dig the target or not.
I hope this helps, good luck. The 2500 is a great detector, once you are familiar with it you will be finding great stuff.