I've done a lot of speculating on the sounds of pull-tabs vs nickels and I still get foiled when I think I have it figured out. There are a couple reasons why the sound would be different when you find a pull-tab. One example, it has holes in it and theoretically it should have a bit of a broken sound or not as smooth as a nickel, But this is only rarely observed and most pull-tabs sound off very smooth and solid sounding. But for the same reason that pull-tabs 'should' sound broken or give an odd break sound at the beginning is the same reason why a ring or jewelry with holes in it 'should' also give this broken sound. Again, this is not always observed as some rings will sound off very smooth and you only have the VDI's to help determine whether to dig or not. Several factors have a role in this affect, the type of coil used makes a HUGE difference in sounds created by different targets, angle of target in the ground and if its on its side or flat. The best advice is to join the hardcore crowd and dig those pull-tabs. Long ago I decided I wouldn't get my hopes up on pull-tab signals so that when I dig them I'm not discouraged. Sometimes I get a +16 signal and I'm more interested in digging that than, say, +20. Why? Because a +20 signal in a public park has a much more likelyhood of being a pull-tab and the +16 is "probably" NEITHER a pull-tab nor a nickel.....so the suspense intrigues me to dig.....could it be a ladies gold ring??? Most often when the VDI is just below BOTH pull-tab and Nickels it is nearly always a tin foil ball or a shot .22 cal bullet. When the VDI's are a bit lower +0 to +10 it is most often a smaller piece of tin foil that is not in a ball.