Earthmansurfer, I remembered your questions to one of my earlier posts, so I have been taking note of how I react to signals in all metal. Firstly, I have found that all metal isn't suitable in all situations. There is one park where I hunt occasionally where I was nearly driven nut by the noise in all metal....this particular park has a lot of deep iron, but it also has lots of underground electromagnetic interference. I presume cables running underneath the park. Most other places I have been using all metal have lots of junk, but it is bearable and manageable.
While I'm detecting I take note of the audio first (I do this in discriminate mode too). In all metal, however, there are times when I dont even look at the VDI. This may be (and usually is) because of the sound and the width of the audio target. If the sound is long and drawn out, then it is something large (and probably iron). Sometimes the tone of the audio will vary slightly within the signal, even though the signal will not be drawn out in itself. Withe one of my other machines, this is a definite response to something like steel (e.g. bottle caps). With the Omega, I have found that this is the case also, even though the Omega is only using one tone, It seems the VCO picks up on the wider signal of the iron content of the target, thereby varying the response of the detector to the target (this is my surmising, and I dont rely on any scientific knowledge or knowledge of electronics for this explanation, but it is an explanation which seems reasonable to me, as it supports what I find when I have extracted the target). This change is pitch is very slight, but you dont need super expensive headphones to pick it up. During this process I will also have looked at the screen to see what numbers are showing (to see if there is an obvious iron ID or not) and also to see if the numbers are jumping around. As in disc. mode, a good target can still produce variable numbers on the screen if the target is deep or in soil which is made up of different types of dirt (such as red clay which has been top-dressed with brown loam). Most of the parks I detect fall into this category.
So, in short, I listen to the sound first, then if the identification of the category of the target is not farly obvious to me, I look at the screen for more info..If I'm still wondering, I make repeated passes over the target from different directions, which also helpos to determine the size of the target, pinpoint to get an idea of depth, then if I think it is a good target or if I am still wondering, I probe or dig (depending on where I am).
Hope all this helps...Any information here is from my own experiences, but detecting in all metal was inspired in me by an article by cjc in a magazine many years ago. HH