IBdiggin said:
Hey Doc-----The thing you should know about coin gardens is they don't work as well as natural ground. Seems they need to be seasoned by being in the ground like years---something to do with the mineralization leeching into the soil causing an aura. Depth reality will be much less with a newly seed garden-----------Hope this helps----IB
I have found that unless a new way is done to bury the coins in test gardens anything deeper than 4" gets iffy. I've got two 7" Nickels that is going on two years that still don't act right, I think in all metal I could get them to hit pretty good, but coin hunting I never hunt in that mode. I had a six inch garden that never worked right even after three years, I just dug it up and re-planted it in another location, that's been well over a year ago and its still not working. In an owners manual that came with a Whites metal detector I had at one time, it stated that the problem with test gardens was the "Ground Matrix" gets disrupted.
My brother Ron and I both have tried to think of a way to plant the gardens with a greater level of success. Now, he came up with the idea of digging a small hole down to the depth you want the coin, but not put the coin in the bottom of that hole, but rather at the depth you want the coin slip or press the coin in the undisturbed soil beside the hole and push it over a bit. Then fill the hole back in. As of yet this is an untested process.
Now I have an 8" garden which has a Lager cent and an Indian Head penny that is now going on over three years, for some reason its worked the best, but now that I've let the grass grow over the grave sites that's lifted the coil some more and the coins are just getting hard to reach with the detector due to them probably being over 9" from the coil and over 8" of that in the soil. In this same garden at one time It had a silver half dollar, but after some time I got concerned about it and maybe something happening to it so I dug it up and re-thought the 8" deep idea and I replaced it with a clad half at 7" and that's been well over a year ago and nothing much that I have will hit the 7" half?? (again I think I could using all metal mode)
The 8" garden does the best, but 8" was a bad choice of depth because I measured actual 8" of dirt! then didn't count for the normal range of grass growth on top of that. Now, if my area had less EMI and I could run full throttle then 8" depth wouldn't be such an extreme, but the 8" of dirt, a couple inches of grass, limited range of sensitivity and threshold control makes the 8" to deep to reach.
Doing this over I would not go past 7" of dirt,
I would not dig the dirt from over top of the planted targets, I would dig and side mount them. (even doing this they may still have to season some)
I wouldn't fool with a 2" garden, or a 3" either, just use air testing for that range.
I would plant a 4" garden.
The other thing that I would recommend doing is cleaning the ground of other metal around the garden. That way you will have the best! conditions to test out detectors, No! in the real world your not likely to ever find such conditions, but if your testing a detector and it won't perform in the best conditions, then its performance is going to improve in worse condition. But! at this point at depths beyond 5" in test gardens I've not been able to create even as good of a condition that's found in the normal real world bad conditions!.
Mark