It`s both a water machine and land machine, similar to the ACE 250, yet many many more features and better depth. It`s priced less then most of the machines you mentioned, and under certain conditions, meets and even beats them. I guess what`s missing from your question, is what types of targets are you searching for, what are the mineralization conditions like and how much experience do you have with what machine. Because this is a Garrett forum, and direct comparisons are not allowed on Findmall forums because of the fights that often times start, I will only discuss Garrett metal detectors.
http://www.garrett.com/hobbysite/hbby_division_promotions_us.aspx#