I have a test best setup with a silver dime buried at 6", 7" and 8". I tested both the 5" DD and the 4x6 concentric yesterday using my F75 setup in JE mode, 6 disc, 4 tone, 75 sens. My soil GBs at 60 with .01/.03 Fe.
Both coils easily detect the 6" dime but the 4x6 is the only one that gives a very faint high note on the 7" and 8" dimes. But these signals were very faint and I needed to be right over the target. In real hunting I would have certainly passed over the targets. The 5" DD was absolutely silent on those targets. In addition, the 5" DD is a bit noisier than the 4x6 putting out more high pitched "tics" at the identical SENS level. I wouldn't raise the sens on the 5" any more than I had it.
With a steel bottlecap buried at 4", the 4x6 yields a much more broken audio signal when swept over the center of the coil with a repeatable iron tone when swept at the tip of the coil. The 5" DD responds like the big factory DD giving a clean sound in the center then a repeatable iron tone again when swept at the tip of the coil.
I have a rusty nail buried 1" deep and 6" apart from a silver dime buried at 4". Both coils do an excellent job separating both targets at very high swing speeds with a slight edge going to the 5" DD. The audio was just a little 'cleaner' on the dime compared to the 4x6. You begin to reach the limit of how fast your brain can process both signals. IMHO, neither coil excels over the other, but both coils are far superior compared to the factory 9x11 DD.
Using my 9x11D D, I can see easily see the 7" and 8" targets, with accurate ID, if I swing using a normal to fast swing speed. If I slow down significantly, or do the Minelab 'wiggle', the 7" and 8" targets nearly disappear.
Again, using my 9x11 DD with the nail and dime, the dime is nearly completely masked swinging in either direction unless I swing at a very slow swing speed. Then, the audio is poor at best and only serves notice to examine further (rotate!)