Find's Treasure Forums

Welcome to Find's Treasure Forums, Guests!

You are viewing this forums as a guest which limits you to read only status.

Only registered members may post stories, questions, classifieds, reply to other posts, contact other members using built in messaging and use many other features found on these forums.

Why not register and join us today? It's free! (We don't share your email addresses with anyone.) We keep email addresses of our users to protect them and others from bad people posting things they shouldn't.

Click here to register!



Need Support Help?

Cannot log in?, click here to have new password emailed to you

Changed email? Forgot to update your account with new email address? Need assistance with something else?, click here to go to Find's Support Form and fill out the form.

Minelab which one ????

St Bernard

New member
Looking at several different detectors to buy. Of the Minelab line of detectors which model would be the best all around detector with out spending a few thousand dollars on a Minelab upper end models? E -Trac, Safari, Xtera they have a pretty good line up of detectors. I want a good detector for coin and jewelry and relic mostly. Feedback appreciated Thanks
-------------------
Bill :minelab: :confused:
 
Like most detectors there is a learning curve and feel Minelabs maybe a little more than some like, but once you know them well it is hard to beat them.
Now depending on if you want new or used as my favorite for my coin and jewelry is the Minelab Sovereign GT, but is no longer being made. A good Friend of mine uses a Explorer XS and been using it since 2000 (Wore out 2 of them as he hunts) and been kicking every ones butt as he get 300-400 silver a year, this is because he knows it well. This was the first Explorer made, but he stick with what he knows best and is no longer made, but I seen some on the classified for around $300-$400, so a good used one is a good way to start and if you don't like it you can sell it with out losing much or any at all.
Now if you want to go new than the E-Trac is your best without breaking the bank and the one I like myself of all the Explorer series. For what a Safari cost I myself would go for the E-Trac as it is a little more, but worth it for me. The X-Terras are a lower line detector and are good, but are more relic than coin detectors from what I used them to try out, they do work for coins, but to me no where close to the E-Tracs on deeper coins and those close to trash.


Just my 2 cents worth
Rick
 
That F75 SE/LTD you said you were buying can get the items that you want. It's just as good once you learn it. Did you change your mind on the F75 ? I have the Etrac and the F75 and I am always grabbing the 75 . It can do it all. Even better once you learn what it's telling you. Now the Etrac is great for deep silver with a large coil but so is the F75. The 75 is much , much faster then the Etrac . I do however like running the Etrac also. Imo anyways. GS
 
No I have not given up on the F75 SE / LTD. I was just looking at the Minelab for knowledge. I will go with the Fisher F75 SE/LTD for sure. My son was also looking at Minelab and was asking me questions and now I did gain a little about Minelab to tell him about. Thanks
-----------------
Bill
 
Minelab ... I would look into the
X-terra 705 Get extra coils.. 6X10 HF for your gold detecting... get a MF coil for the parks / coin detecting.
Safari.. Good deep seeker not to good for gold detecting ... good coins / parks and great for the beach
SE & E-trac are OK If you like the programs / menus they just have more vdi number to do a more fine selection

The Fisher F2 might be a good option for your son..not to expensive to see if he is really into this hobby also has a good resale value to sale for a upgrade
 
Rick's answer is very good. Stick with the explorer series (II, SE pro, Etrac, etc...) And get the Sunray inline probe if you can find one. This setup is what all the top dogs are using nowadays it seems. Especially turf hunters trying to sniff out deep silver in junky parks. And while they're not going to see a coin through multiple nails at a ghost-townsy site like some of the 2 filter machines (and various fishers, etc...), yet for the power-house that they are, do quite well in relicky ghost-townsy sites. I use mine (the II and the SE pro) all the time in relicky old-town demolition and ghost-townsy sites. And keep up with all sorts of specialty machines supposedly for better-in-iron (deus, etc...).

And as Rick pointed out: If you look at the statistics of who's bringing in the silver from park turf, they are almost always swinging one of the explorer lineups. What does that tell you ? But as he also says: The learning curve is hard. Best way is to hook up with someone proficient in your area and trade off flagged signals. Or if no one to train you: go to a place prolific with easy clad: Set it to reject everything below copper pennies. Dig 100 targets (which would all be only clad pennies, dimes, quarters, etc...). Next day repeat the exercise, but this day, lower the mask so that you accept zinc. Repeat. Next day lower the mask to accept corroded zincs and the larger beefier square tabs. Repeat. Next day lower to accept round tabs, repeat. And so forth, and so on, till you're finally in all metal mode, letting your ears hear the orchestra. Make sure you're in ferrous mode, if you intend to hear all, including iron.
 
Top