Harpsoft, For the average person who does not know how to properly run a Gold Detector, the answer is YES.. insane to even try.
A real Gold Detector will respond to all metal targets (ferrous and nonferrous). Some Gold Detectors can ID most ferrous, so you don't have to dig as much iron... BUT... at a school or park, there are literally hundreds of signals per every 10 feet. The mover comes along and chops pull tabs into 3 pieces. aluminum foil (gum and cigarette wrappers), BB's, bobby pins, staples, zippers, needles, screw caps, pencil erasers and everything else will respond. You need to know that gold machine like you know your wife.. if not, the chances are very low the average person would be successful.
last year I was called to find a 1/2 karat diamond stud ear ring. The post and stud were platinum and that was the only metal on there. I took over my Minelab Explorer SE Pro and the X-Terra 70 and no luck. I tried the White's MXT and DFX with no luck. My main problem was electrical interference and I could not get any of the detectors (no matter what I did) to shut up. The daughter, the mom and the grandmother were all out there looking on their hands on knees. I felt bad for not finding it, but nothing I could do. I told her I would come back early the next morning and try again.
Next day I arrive and have the Fisher Gold Bug-2. The electrical interference is hardly there at all and so I am in good condition to run the detector. The only problem is...there must have need 3 targets every sweep I made. So what do you do in this situation????
I asked to see and listen to the other earring. I put it on the ground and swung over it 20 times from all directions. I had to listen to the signal strength, the pitch, the width and signal drop off. I also noticed what seemed like a quick double beep. Now most of you don't have thousands of hours on a GB-2, but I have than much and then some.. After that I only went for the exact targets sounds and 5 minutes and 2 targets later I had it in my hand.
Talk about tears of joy flowing everywhere. They cried with so much joy.. it started to get to me...Yes, a grown man who they don't even know is standing in their back yard with a detector in hand and all glossy eyed..
They persisted that I take $50 for my time.. Heck, I was just happy to find the thing.
This situation was like finding a needle in a hay stack and the chances were really stacked against most people.
I really do think the X-70 or MXT would have found it provided the electrical interference was not there. I have done very well hunting small gold jewelry with both the MXT and the X-70.
Just so you know... Many bracelets and necklaces do not give off a very good signal at all, especially if they are gold. Test one with your own detector and I think you will see what I mean.
Good Luck, Gerry