Find's Treasure Forums

Welcome to Find's Treasure Forums, Guests!

You are viewing this forums as a guest which limits you to read only status.

Only registered members may post stories, questions, classifieds, reply to other posts, contact other members using built in messaging and use many other features found on these forums.

Why not register and join us today? It's free! (We don't share your email addresses with anyone.) We keep email addresses of our users to protect them and others from bad people posting things they shouldn't.

Click here to register!



Need Support Help?

Cannot log in?, click here to have new password emailed to you

Changed email? Forgot to update your account with new email address? Need assistance with something else?, click here to go to Find's Support Form and fill out the form.

Key date Canadian nickel

Ronstar

Well-known member
Decided to make a last minute run at that old city park before the cold spell hits this week. I simply was making a wandering pattern just to see if there might be another hot spot like the other area with early 1900s coins.
I managed to find a few clads and a bunch of bottle caps but then I hit an odd number in the 40s (on The Legend just above dime but below caps) and curiosity made me dig. Took me a bit to find it in the dark rich dirt but I finally saw the circular curved edge of a coin. At first I thought it was a foreign coin or play coin but when I turned it over I saw “5 cents” and Canada……carefully brushed it off and saw 1925!! Officially my oldest Canadian coin. A few minutes later I found what for all intents and purposes was a silver quarter but it too was foriegn! More on that in a bit.

Got home and did the usual Google search and found out the nickel is a key date and low mintage! Only 200k minted and in basic shape $50 value!!!! SCORE!!!!!
Now the other coin…….
Got it cleaned up and it’s a 1957 “One Schilling” coin and thought it too was Canadian until the Google search. Looks like English but could be Australian but then again English is a more closer match. Now the conundrum….. This was 5-6” deep and just as shiny coming up outta mama earth as a known silver coin does. Search reveals if English it is a copper nickel mix and should not be shiny should it. But wait there is a silver version for Australia but wait again the date stamp is in the wrong place. What do I have??????

Oh yeah, as soon as the deep freeze leaves I’m going back to that “foreign” corner!!!

As you can see that Schilling is shiny in the hole, I cant find any reference to a silver proof having been done either.
 

Attachments

  • 0EEA9B59-659E-475B-A185-D760914AD7F1.jpeg
    0EEA9B59-659E-475B-A185-D760914AD7F1.jpeg
    2 MB · Views: 119
  • C53DAF91-F02F-4C75-B1EC-FC8FA79910B2.jpeg
    C53DAF91-F02F-4C75-B1EC-FC8FA79910B2.jpeg
    1.8 MB · Views: 112
  • 4E473192-7FC0-45D4-9DE3-E07DFB65F2FC.png
    4E473192-7FC0-45D4-9DE3-E07DFB65F2FC.png
    2.7 MB · Views: 111
  • F3AA7A97-B451-4551-A185-8161B0774578.jpeg
    F3AA7A97-B451-4551-A185-8161B0774578.jpeg
    2.2 MB · Views: 112
Nice saves ,,
Finding them saves on a last hunt is gonna definetly keep your enthusiasm going to hit that place again when the weather breaks .
 
Super score on the Canadian Nickel !! I’m not familiar with the Schilling composition but it sure looks like silver. What kind of TID did it provide? Is it close to a silver reading?
I looked it up and it is from Great Britain and indeed copper / nickel. Regardless, nice find!!
 
Last edited:
Jimmy, it hit like a quarter should, 51-52. Im still somewhat baffled by the nickel though, it was pretty much a solid 47 and caps have been constant 48-49 and dimes 46. And yes, I rechecked the plug and several inches around the plug from different angles and no other responses. I had it hard in my my head that nickels can skew other targets VIDs and was hoping something larger in the pot. I also know I will go back once the weather warms and recheck.
Still trying to find out if any silver proofs were made on that coin. If so then I’m wondering if someones coin collection was taken and some of the spoils spilled out in the escape.
 
Still researching the nickel…..
It is the same size as our nickel but it is 100% nickel and not .750 copper and .250 nickel like ours. Wondering if that is why it rang so high……?
 
Interesting finds Ron, but I can’t help you with the high reading on the nickel.
War nickels occasionally give much higher readings than normal I have found.
Could be like you stated.. 100% nickel composition may be the reason.
That other coin sure looks like silver.
 
Still researching the nickel…..
It is the same size as our nickel but it is 100% nickel and not .750 copper and .250 nickel like ours. Wondering if that is why it rang so high……?
I’m sure that nickel would fetch much more then $50. That’s a beauty and the
scarcest of all Canadian Nickels!!
I agree with fwcrawford, due to the pure nickel content, this could certainly be the reason for higher TID. You made a super find!!
 
Thinking I might take that nickel up to the folks that looked at my friends $20 Double Eagle…… there are light surface scratches and such but the detail on the coin is quite sharp. Maybe professionally cleaned? Cost to restore vs potential collector value, uggg.
 
Top