First I want to say that if you were here I'd shake your hand. You are one of the few honest THers I think I've ever met online.
If this were on the ___________ forum you'd be getting dimes at 18 inches in the dirt.
Okay, the air tests aren't that great but that coil should handle the minerals in all soils a lot better plus you have better ground coverage. And we all know Tesoros, the real test comes in actual treasure hunting.
What machine are you using?
I just tested my Cutlass II uMax with the stock brown donut coil and this is what I get in air tests:
Note: I moved the coins by the coil slower like my swing speed (no whipping coins past the coil for a false exaggerated reading).
Both dime and quarter coins get the same air distance.
Very strong smooth signal at 7 inches and a broken sometimes signal at about 8.5 inches (if I whip the coin YouTube style I can get 10+ inches).
Sum: average in dirt depth for both dimes and quarters = 6 inches (mild soil 65).
Copper coins do better with Tesoros, copper wheats and nickels will air test well about 8 inches and in the dirt both will sound solid at about 7 inches deep.
The above test of my Cutlass is almost exactly what I found with my Fisher F-75.
I have used the 12x10 uMax concentric on a Silver uMax and it goes a lot deeper on coins than the stock 8 inch coil. It will go a good 2-3 inches deeper. But the coil is bulky and not good for heavy brush hunting due to the web design.
I would really like to try the 10 1/2 inch uMax donut shaped concentric which I understand some dealers still have them. I may order one soon.