Each of the X-Terra coils are designed with certain "criteria" in mind. In other words, some are just better than others for specific jobs. The higher frequency elliptical fulfills a need for many nugget hunters and other low conductive targets. (e.g. beach hunting) It is lightweight, covers more "area" than the 9-inch concentrics or smaller 6-inch coils. And, the DD design is preferred by those hunting in highly mineralized areas. I don't live near beaches nor do I live near an area that has the opportunity to hunt gold. And my soil is moderately mineralized. Although I woulnd't consider the elliptical coil to be "poor", as a coin shooter, I feel there are other X-Terra coil choices that are a better fit for my particular needs. HH Randy
http://www.minelab.com/usa/consumer/knowledge-base/faq#2546
X-TERRA: Which is the right type of coil to use?
There are two issues to consider - frequency and coil type and size. Your choice of coil will depend on the type of ground you want to search and the types of targets you wish to find. Double-D coils are best suited to mineralised ground. A 10.5" Double-D coil is well suited to beach detecting. Double-D coils provide the best depth. Concentric coils suit soils that are cluttered with many individual targets - both wanted and unwanted. Pinpointing is sharper on concentric coils.
High frequency coils, such as the 18.75 kHz 10" x 5" elliptical coil, are recommended for gold hunting and for searching productive ancient sites where low conductivity items are more likely to be found. High frequency detecting can result in an increased tendency to signal more ferrous (unwanted) items. Smaller 6" coils are ideal for finding jewellery in manicured lawns, cluttered sites where wanted and unwanted targets might be located very close to each other, gold nugget hunting in rocky areas and working in shallow streams.