EZrider,
Last summer I got a small 9k ring (unusual to find 9k here) that was scratchy low to mid tone bounce one way and low tone the other. When it was up and out of the scoop, it air tested solid midtone. Did not notice iron in the scoop when it came up, but would not be surprised if there was a little iron decomposing very close to the ring in the clay bottom that I found it in. Also recently got a scratchy mid-tone hit at the local beach that was a silver ring with a break in the band. Picture of that dirty silver ring is below in the walk with the CZ-20 post.
Many do give good solid smooth sounding tones, but some do not.
tvr