Comparing these two detectors would be like comparing apples to oranges. i like both equally well, but for different reasons. This question always goes back to asking yourself some of the basics. What kind of hunting do you plan to do more with your detector? If you are planning on tot lots and small areas near metal structures and smaller areas the compadre is hard to beat. If you are wanting something with depth and ground coverage you are looking for the vaquero. 2nd, how familiar are you with using Tesoros? The vaquero is more complex than the Compadre for a first time tesoro user. It has manual ground balance and a few more switches and knobs. The compadre is simple turn on and go with a preset ground balance and only one knob to fiddle with and you are hunting In seconds. 3rd, what kind of treasure are you planning to go after. If you are a coin shooter for older coins and also for relics that are deeper in the ground, I would say vaquero. The compadre has found me some older stuff, including silver coins, but that is only when I do the research and the targets are only so deep. If you are wanting to hunt for jewelry in parks, yards or tot lots or clad coins and don't have a desire to dig a pull tab at 7" I would get a compadre. I don't mind digging deep, but there are days I just want to recover the target quickly and move on. The compadre has found me more gold and silver items and the smallest pieces as well as the larger pieces than any other detector I have had in the past or that I have now. Not to mention finding a 1935 D buffalo Nickle, a 1945 S war Nickle and other silver coins. If you want to hunt for gold or silver jewelry I would say Compadre. There are many other questions that I could ask myself to decide which of these 2 detectors to purchase, but the last one I will throw out there is , how often do you plan to use your detector, or how much time will you get to use it? I don't get out all that much to detect these days, so having a detector that works amazingly well, cost me only $160 and at a certain depth can find me all the goodies, the compadre was just a no brainer. However, they are both great detectors and you are going to like either one. These are just my opinions and hopefully others will chime in. These are just some questions I like to ask myself before making a new detector purchase and I have found them helpful. Good luck and best wishes.