Not sure of another's post, but perhaps you are reading into my post last night saying that particular Indian head was a 55? Then you look at the manual's probability chart that says this.....
aluminum pull-tab 33-55
Now, remember tabs are not all made the same, and I believe that big span was written like that basically to be safe & encompass beaver tails/round, etc. Also, you have 1/2 a tab & folded over round tails...all read different. But, I have a boxful of tabs of all different shapes/sizes at home, & they all hit alot lower than 55. More like 35-40's I believe (again I'm at work, but will look at this later). Gutta start bringing my notes to work
A "high end" conductive tab in the 55 range is rare, and more like those big old pudding ones I think. We studied tabs in depth once for the Coinstrike notches....
Also, not to make excuses, but keep in mind that particlar 1882 indian head is worn pretty thin on the front & I was lucky to get a date even. So, that reading was perhaps less than normal for an Indian. I would think many would be up closer to 60 & zincs, but again this needs to be tested more. That too will bother some notchers, so it's a double edged sword....Notching & indian heads is always a challenge to the hobby.
If your looking at the photo below of the LCD, it may appear tabs go up to 55. But, don't take words in the upper blocks too literally as they basically just give you a broad idea (I usually don't even look at the squares, just the number). Again, I need my notes & will do some further testing this weekend on both tabs, indian heads, & UK coins as promiced for our friends abroad. But, I don't see a tabs issue in my testing thusfar, but perhaps a 11" indian head or one in bad soil may read lower or even higher? See, keep in mind unlike most ID units, instead of dropping down the number on a deep target...the f75 "up averages" it! From the manual...
The F75 has a tendency to up-average nonferrous targets in the proximity of iron, indicating ID numbers higher than would be obtained in an air test. This tendency is connected with the F75