Find's Treasure Forums

Welcome to Find's Treasure Forums, Guests!

You are viewing this forums as a guest which limits you to read only status.

Only registered members may post stories, questions, classifieds, reply to other posts, contact other members using built in messaging and use many other features found on these forums.

Why not register and join us today? It's free! (We don't share your email addresses with anyone.) We keep email addresses of our users to protect them and others from bad people posting things they shouldn't.

Click here to register!



Need Support Help?

Cannot log in?, click here to have new password emailed to you

Changed email? Forgot to update your account with new email address? Need assistance with something else?, click here to go to Find's Support Form and fill out the form.

Advice on which detector to get

sissylala69s

New member
Hi
I'm new to detecting and am looking for advice about the best unit for me
I realize everyone's opinion is different but am hoping that if I tell y'all what my goals and budget are, I can finally make a decision
I have researched til I thought my head was going to explode and I'm no closer to a decision than when I started looking 2 weeks ago
1st of all, my budget is $200
I'd like something that will truly differentiate between coins, gold, bottle caps, cans, can tops, nails, screws, nuts,rebar, etc
AND that is user friendly with easily adjustable settings?
The sensitivity/all metal/disc etc settings on H.F. unit were terrible....the tones all sounded the same and it didn't ignore ANY metal
Writing this, I'm wondering if it's realistic to think I can find a user friendly, easily adjustable unit that actually differentiates between metals and doesn't take forever to learn to use for less than $200...a girl can dream right?
Thanks in advance
 
Ummm well , the machine that can truly differentiate all those targets hasnt been invented yet but any decent machine with practice certainly will give you a better idea of whats down there.. under $200 is your biggest obstacle, they show up every so often in used detectors forum at the bottom of the page..i would imagine anything would be better than harbor freight unit but I don't know as i havent used one.. there was an omega tecknetics that was for sale for $195 back in December, that would have a great unit for the money... perhaps a used ace 250 or simular unit would suffice till you find enough loot to trade up..good luck...
 
Of the machines in your price range ($200 or less) the only one that I've used is the Tesoro Compadre. It is a very capable machine - light in weight, good build quality, fast recovery, and it is a blast to use. It's also a very easy machine to learn. It isn't a deep machine though (about 6-7 inches max) and the ground balance is pre-set. It is pretty much a turn it on, set the discrimination where you want it (say - foil) and dig every target that beeps. There's only the one tone though, but in time you'll learn that a good target just sounds better somehow.

It doesn't have a pin-point mode though (it isn't needed) and there is no depth meter (again - not really needed). Unless you thumb the discrimination knob (while swinging over a target) you won't have a real clue as to what the target is - until you've dug the target.

The major brands all offer entry level machines - all of which will be superior to the HF machine (both in build quality and performance).

Contact a forum sponsor (one of the dealers here) for great service and price. I highly recommend Richard at Backwoodsmetaldetectors.com
 
Thanks, I'll do that
Since I'm normally a "Buy now, kick myself later" kind of person am pretty proud of myself for not rushing out and buying the 1st detector I saw that claimed to be everything I'm looking for
How much more (than $200) would you say I need to spend to get something that discriminates metals better than average, shows depth, has obvious tones and is easy to adjust?
If it's not a huge jump, I'd rather wait and get what I'll be happy with
I don't suppose there are units available that xray the ground so you can see a picture of what's there, then go all transformer & dig the item up for you...AFTER it brings you a beer, are there?
J/k
What fun would that be?
 
sissylala69s said:
Thanks, I'll do that
Since I'm normally a "Buy now, kick myself later" kind of person am pretty proud of myself for not rushing out and buying the 1st detector I saw that claimed to be everything I'm looking for
How much more (than $200) would you say I need to spend to get something that discriminates metals better than average, shows depth, has obvious tones and is easy to adjust?
If it's not a huge jump, I'd rather wait and get what I'll be happy with
I don't suppose there are units available that xray the ground so you can see a picture of what's there, then go all transformer & dig the item up for you...AFTER it brings you a beer, are there?
J/k
What fun would that be?

Your funny LOL :rofl: Welcome to the forum... Check with one of the sponsors..They can advise you..or if there is a dealer near you stop by look at all the detectors and then make your choice..... Click on the banners at top of forums..Read about their products... I am still working on getting my detector to bring me a beer and dig up the target.... Oh make sure you do buy a good digger when you get the detector...... and consider a pin pointer too...
 
I crack myself up all the time
There is not a single store that sells them in my little one horse town
The nearest place that sells them is 2 hours away
I thought there'd be more interest in my area cuz there's a lot of gold mining but no clubs came up
Anyway, thanks for the replies
 
A road trip to get the right detector would be well worth while...... contacting one of our sponsors would be worth while too....
A sponsor list is at the top of the first page when you log on..
 
You don't need to spend a ton of money to get a great, capable detector.

Back in 2010 I bought a $200 detector, a Fisher F2, over the next 3 years I used that thing and it paid for itself more than 10x's it's cost.
Clad galore, some relics, older coins and a whole bunch of silver and gold jewelry.
Not a ton of really old coins and silver coins because I was mostly a jewelry hunter at the time but I still found many.
It was simple and basic with only a few adjustments but they were enough because I learned the target behavior so well which is exactly what I do with every detector I own.

The current Fisher lineup got rid of the F2 but replaced it The F22...for around your $200 price point.
Light years ahead of that HF unit, great disc, lots of clues using both tones and screen into behavior...as would be a few others also near that price.
Stick to the major american brands and you should be ok.
 
sissylala69s said:
I crack myself up all the time
There is not a single store that sells them in my little one horse town
The nearest place that sells them is 2 hours away
I thought there'd be more interest in my area cuz there's a lot of gold mining but no clubs came up
Anyway, thanks for the replies

Check this out there a website called Amazon
You can pay over the internet (wait for it)
They will ship it to your door. Holy Cow
 
I would probably go with REVIER's suggestion and get a Fisher F22 or a Teknetics Delta 4000. The Teknetics is right in your price range (for a brand new one). For a total newbie it's easier to set up than an F22, it's light, has an easy to read screen and is a very close relative to the more complex, more expensive and well liked Omega. You could also go second hand and if ever you decide that whatever model you chose is not for you, just sell the detector and lose very little if anything.
 
u2robert said:
Check this out there a website called Amazon
You can pay over the internet (wait for it)
They will ship it to your door. Holy Cow

No way?!?
Are you pulling my leg?
Hmm Learn something new every day
Problem being, I want a metal detector
I don't have any use for webs
Or Amazons for that matter
But gosh, thanks for the SUPER helpful input
 
Thanks for (almost) all the input, suggestions and advice
I bought the HF unit on a whim, (aka buy now, kick later) and I thought it was representative of a low end unit
I was leery of spending a couple hundred bucks to end up with eleventy billion bottle caps, beer tabs, soda cans, nails and a couple hundred 10 year old crusty pennies
But with everything said here, I realize that it was lower than the lower end of a low end unit lol
I am going to Oklahoma this week and plan on looking when I'm there
I'm hoping they'll be cheaper there but since I'm flying, I'm not sure if it will be a problem at the airport (on my way home)
I guess I'll have to look Wonder Woman up and ask her to arrange for an Amazonian deliver it to my door
 
Amazon is just one of many companies that sell detectors. Any of the sponsors on here can help you and there are many ways to have it shipped. I prefer the Postal Service but that's because I worked there 34+ years. Good luck.
 
No, I haven't gotten one yet
I just got to Ok Tuesday and have been seeing family the last couple of days
I'm hoping to start shopping for one this weekend
Any suggestions on specific stores or search terms to bring up local stores w/out having to weed through all the online sites?
I know I can get one online but I'm more of a "hands on" shopper
Oh, and I'm in Podunk, Ok aka BFE
Closest decent sized town is 2 hours away but there's a couple of big name Sporting Goods and Dept stores w/in an hour
 
sissylala69s said:
No, I haven't gotten one yet
I just got to Ok Tuesday and have been seeing family the last couple of days
I'm hoping to start shopping for one this weekend
Any suggestions on specific stores or search terms to bring up local stores w/out having to weed through all the online sites?
I know I can get one online but I'm more of a "hands on" shopper
Oh, and I'm in Podunk, Ok aka BFE
Closest decent sized town is 2 hours away but there's a couple of big name Sporting Goods and Dept stores w/in an hour


There are not a whole lot of metal detector stores out there, if you are lucky you live near one with a knowledgeable owner and decent stock but most in this country don't have one handy.
Some drive hours to get to one, many wouldn't do that if you paid them.

Some smaller businesses might have some supplies, a pawn shop near me bought good and silver at a decent spot price and he also sold a couple of detectors and a few accessories but that is rare, too.

You have but his stores, Costco sells at least one, Wal-Mart sells some as does some sporting goods stores and places like Cabela's but you never have anywhere a full choice of what is out there...you have to pick from what they have.

Maybe at an actual detector dealer store you might get a chance at some hands on shopping, some let you hold them, listen to them and even have areas on-site you can actually hunt to see how they handle.
At big box or most other stores that sell a few brands of models you usually don't have a shot at handling them before you buy, just standing there holding a sealed box won't help you much.

Since you live in a small town you might not have anything close to you at all.

If you order online you will have a choice of a few different kinds of sites.
Many brick and mortar stores also have a website, they would love if you came in but if you can't the good ones will actually spend as much time as needed talking on the phone or messaging answering questions and try to sell you the right machine, not just the most expensive.
Lots of competition online, the smart ones know if you equalize most other factors most everything is about customer service...that is how to get...and keep loyal customers.
The sponsor list below has many dealers like this.

There are dealers that don't have a physical store, everything is online and depending on volume you might get a discount because these types don't have the brick and mortar costs.
Some still give great service online and over the phone, some don't...you just have to call them and see or look to reviews to narrow it down to the best ones.
There is a Feedback Forum here that is used for just this purpose.

Like in the real world there are good dealers/businessmen out there and there are bad ones.
Word on the bad ones travels pretty quickly.I

Ordering from dealers online you have a few advantages.
Better service before, during and after the sale than many physical stores...and way more knowledge.

Most ship free if you hit certain price points.
$200 should do it.
No sales tax, no shipping costs...I consider that a discount.

Discounts...an often asked question.
Physical stores, the price marked is usually it unless you but a sale.
Online stores, the prices you see advertised on most models are usually all exactly the same...have you noticed that yet?
Some gussy them up with packages and throw in some accessories, (which range from useless to decent), most sell just the unit by itself like a la carte and then you buy any anything extra on the side.

The thing to know is those prices are all the same for a reason...The manufacturers demand they do it that way.
MAP...minimum advertised price.
Start advertising anything below this price disrupting the market and you will usually not get any more product sent to you.
HOWEVER, CALL THEM OR CONTACT THEM DIRECTLY AND THEY ARE FREE TO DISCOUNT AS MUCH AS THEY WANT TO GET YOU AS A CUSTOMER!

Some will throw in extra discounts, some won't, you just have to call around and see.


Here is the way I look at this.
If I had an actual, decently stocked physical store with a knowledgeable and honest hunter/owner near me that would be the place.
I would pay the price he asks if it was fairly competative, I would pay the sales tax and everything else.
I owned a retail store, I want this guy to make a profit to pay to keep his doors open so he will be there for me in the future.
I want him to make a little for himself, for many it is a labor of love but they deserve some reward for helping others as long as he is not screwing me over.
Online usually has a price advantage but sometimes the lowest price isn't always the best deal...especially if something goes wrong and you are dealing with company that doesn't understand what good service means.

Online I go with the dealers I have seen great feedback about it ones I have already dealt with in the past.
Good price, fast, free shipping, in stock and available, this is what I look for.
Big Boys Hobbies http://www.bigboyshobbies.net/
This is Bart, just one guy off the list below that I know is good because I have gotten a few things from him.
I swear he must have a post office in his store because I get notifications of the item being entered into the system before we even get off the phone.
He is in Oklahoma by the way.

All the dealers in that list have many, many loyal repeat customers.



Hands on is good, I prefer that myself, but in this hobby the bulk of us don't have access to a good, local store.
So we call around and try to find someone that listens to what we think we need and gives us good advice.
With luck we get a decent, logical, capable detector at a decent price without being oversold and then something happens that is not fun, can be frustrating as heck but so many of us have gone through it.
We call it The Wait...harder than you might think but we usually get our stuff in a couple of days.
Remember how hard it was to wait for Christmas morning back when you were a kid, yea, like that.
Maybe worse.

I would much rather check things out thoroughly as I could and find the best one for me possible than buy just anything to get going immediately.
As a newbie and staying in the lower entry level price this is most important...it is possible you can get a great detector at a lower price but you also can get junk.
I do this hobby for fun, I don't need extra hassles.
Waiting a few days is important if it gets me something I can enjoy, ending up with one you are not happy with because it was the only thing on a shelf I would not enjoy...but that is me.

Some have gone out and bought the first detector they came across and it worked out so that is also possible.


This all becomes easier as you gain knowledge and get ready to buy your next one.
Yea, that is very common in this hobby, after you swing for awhile you learn things about yourself....what features you like, what features you would like to have, weight, tones, programming coils...you know much more about all of that so you can choose your next one much easier.is
If you stay in the hobby because some do and some don't for several reasons.


Good luck!






Backwoods Detector Sales http://www.backwoodsmetaldetectors.com/
Big Boys Hobbies http://www.bigboyshobbies.net/
Coiltek Manufacturing http://www.coiltek.com.au/
DeepTech USA http://www.deeptech-bg.com/
Fisher Metal Detectors http://www.fisherlab.com/
Garrett Metal Detectors http://www.garrett.com/
Indian Nations Detector sales http://www.indiannationsdetectors.com/

JMT Metal Detectors http://jmtmetaldetectors.com/
Kellyco Metal Detectors https://www.kellycodetectors.com/
Metaldetectors.com http://www.metaldetectors.com/
Minelab http://www.minelab.com/
Nokta/Makro Detection technologies http://noktadetectors.com
North Georgia Relics http://northgeorgiarelics.com/contact-us/
Reilly's Treasured Gold http://rtgstore.com/morescoops.htm
River Team Six Metal Detectors http://www.rt6detectors.com/
Vance Metal Detectors http://www.vancemetaldetectors.com/
Windycitydetectors Sales & Rentals http://www.windycitydetectors.com/
XP Detectors http://www.treasurehuntingoutfitters.com
 
The price that you see on places like amazon and on dealers web sites are the Minimum price that they are allowed to advertise.

Most dealers will give you a little better price on a detector. There are some very good dealers that sponsor this forum. I like Richard at Backwoods and Bart at Big Boys as both are very knowledgeable and will help you in what will best fill your needs.
 
Hi,
to do what your are asking:correctly identify coins, gold, pull-tabs, cans, screw caps, crown caps, nails, nuts, rebar etc. you are going to need a Minelab Etrac or a Minelab CTX 3030. Add 1 to 2 THOUSAND dollars to your budget.
The best detectors within your budget may be two First Texas products=Fisher F22 ($219) and Teknetics Ameritek Minuteman ($149) tekneticsdirect.com. You get plenty of features on both along with excellent target separation and target recover speed, decent depth and a 5 year warranty.

Jeff
 
I bought a Technetics Delta 4000 with DD coil for my step son a few years ago. Of all the detectors I have had over the years it turned out to be a great little beginner machine with features of more expensive machines, simple settings and menus, only used one 9 volt battery that lasted a good while, and in my area would bang on six and seven inch coins all day long. They still offer that machine for around 300 with a concentric coil.
 
Check out the Nokta Makro Simplex - that's going to be a lot of detector for not a lot of dollars. The Quest X5 at $169 and X10 at $199 are looking good too.
 
Top