Bud,
Bills question is key....perhaps you missed the point.... there is a difference between "notching buy segment" and "notching a specifically identified target". Although you use the elim button to apply the notch, the segments could be very different.
This is verbose but from what you've told us, I don't know a simple answer.
If you find a specific target (pull-tab) and you immediately notch it out with the "eliminate" button, it will eliminate "the specific notch" which ID that target. This may or may not be where the 250 says pull-tabs should be.
If you notch it out by simply eliminating what the 250 says is the segment for "pull tabs", you definitely won't eliminate them completely.
Just as the detector is not 100% accurate in ID-ing correct coin values 100% of the time, neither can it ID "pull-tabs" 100% of the time. Target conductivity is just not that repeatable in the real world.
In the same way dimes and quarters sometimes show up a notch out of position sometimes, so do pull tabs of various conductivities.
I've often dug dimes that ID as quarters (and vice-versa)
I've often dug nickels that identified as foil or tabs
I've often dug pennies that ID as dimes (and vice-versa)
Other operator considerations .... when you notch out segments on the ACE it still finds "everything" and indicates "everything" on the ID scale. However, the ACE will NOT output an audio tone for those segments/ranges that are notched out.
Also, you could be getting fooled by a brief audio tone for a moment if the target is "jumping around" and occasionally hits a segment that is not notched out. So one scenario is the you hear a brief beep, pinpoint the target and dig a pull-tab.
Also, when you pinpoint, the ACE runs in "all metal" mode and does not honor the notches so it's quite possible you have multiple targets and got the pull-tab.
I hate to be so vague but you really have to give a lot more detail as to how you notched and how you actually found the tabs you thought you had eliminated.
Hope I didn't just confuse the situation.