A question about detector brand.

[jayhop]

I've had my mxt for a week now and i am already thinking about getting another detector. without considering the cost.
are three those here that would rather have a another brand.
i like my mxt, don't get me wrong.its just that when i get hooked on something new i like to use the best equipment that i can afford.
I'm sure that one brand might have some features that another don't.
the main thing I'm talking about is depth and accuracy.
I've heard alot about tht explore SE.
any thoughts?
jay

 

[popsmoke]

I think you've got, arguably, one of the best detectors out there - for coins and relics that is. For the beach it will do quite well too.

I've got both, the SE and MXT (as well as a DFX) and I think the MXT is easier to use, just as hot - perhaps hotter, and is one dam fine machine.

Though - here comes another opinion now...

 

[jayhop]

is that what you ment when you said hot? or hotter?
jay

 

[DFX-Gregg]

Jay I am a little confused....You just got this detector which if you read the posts is a very good one! How deep do you really want to dig? Let's see, the gold ring I found last week was 4.5 inches, the silver ring the week before 2.5 inches, the silver dime the other day 2 inches....Get my point...I would try to learn the machine you have! I have a DFX, I do not regret getting it and continue to learn how to use it. If you move away from the White's brand you may regret it! I have had nothing but great service from them. Is minlab deeper, according to tests yes! So what....I think if you read the posts within the White's brand the depth and finds are just fine, good luck Gregg.

 

[jayhop]

Thank you Gregg.
At this time i am pleased with my MXT. i have used it almost every day since i got it a little over a week ago. i have learned a lot in the last week and i know i have a lot more to learn. the main thing is that i have really enjoyed myself. so much that i would like to have a second machine for someone else to use.before i get a second machine i want to take my time and feel like one of the machines is about the best that i can get within reason.
as far as how deep do i want to dig? i will mainly be walking farm fields where there used to be an old house site or near a civil war site.i will be covering a lot of ground and finding few good targets to dig,i don't mind digging a deep hole once in a while.
i just don't want to miss anything.
i did walk a early 1920's school yard without finding any silver although i did find about 20 coins 1980 and younger.
that makes me wonder if the silver is deeper and i missed it.or someone else picked it clean years ago.

jay

 

[stumpr]

Jayhop,

I am a relic hunter with 20+ years under the belt. I love my MXT for depth and it's capability to sniff out good target in junk laden camps. I also have a Minelab Quattro that I also like but don't get the same depth as I do with MXT with the stock coils that each machine is sold with. The Quattro is primarily a stripped down version of a SE with less "bells and whistles". It takes some time to learn the different sounds of the Minelab. Both machines have their uses. I do believe the Quattro or SE may be a better hot ground machine than the MXT from my experience. Will test the theory again soon.

 

[DFX-Gregg]

From what I have heard if you are hunting old farm houses and areas with possible relics the>>>>MXT is the right machine!!!! Good luck Gregg

 

[deathwind1]

because of there Arm getting sore--I can name three in my detecting club! Is there anyone you can borrow one from to try it for 3-4 hrs to see how it affects Your Arm! That is the reason I don't own one---Its not only Wt. they seem to be not comfortable to use as Whites---

 

[khouse]

To be honest - no matter what brand or model - one week is not enough time to make any decision. Having read your posts you made no mention of weight being an issue. Also you said you wanted another detector for others to use. You can buy a complimentary detector. Meaning a detector of a different frequency. IE. what good if on an iffy target with your MXT to have a M6? You can ask the user of the M6 to check your iffy target to see if it's digable - but they both have the same frequency. Not really going to be a good cross reference. Now if you buy a used Classic ID or IDX and have your partner check your iffy MXT target then you'll get more info to dig or not. For ease of use and light in weight you can use as stated - Used Whites ID or IDX. Whites Prizm 2 or 4. Or if you want another brand I would suggest a Garrett Ace 250.

 

[clondike clad]

MXT and M6 Can pick up coins 10 plus inches or more deep.
I can say 99.9 percent of all my coins are less than the 5 inch mark.
So it come dowm to what detector you like and learn what the detector is telling you.Learning the detector will TAKE SOME TIME.

 

[Kelley (Texas)]

should also be of concern. Depth of detection is of concern in areas that have been heavily hunted, and the deeper the coin size target the less accurate the I.D. of the target. Most coins will be found at a depth of six inches or less and target masking will be a major factor to take into consideration. I recommend that you concentrate on learning the proper use of your MXT for several months before you even think about buying a second metal detector. The MXT is a good metal detector...a reliable work horse that will get the job done for you. I wish you the best in your new chosen hobby. Kelley (Texas)