Rick said:
Has anybody compared these coils with the Vaquero or Tejon. I'm giving a thought to get the 5x10 for my Tejon.
I am debating to get the 5x10 dd or the 5.75 concentric.
Matter of fact, I have tried all of the Tesoro coils on the Tejón as well as two aftermarket NEL coils, both elliptical DD designs, and I have used all of Tesoro's 5-pin coils on the lower-frequency models.
It is difficult to provide a complete answer to your question without knowing the type of hunting you plan to do and the site conditions where you will be searching, so I'll just share my personal opinions from experience. Other than my two OLD Compass detectors, I have ten detectors from three manufacturers. On my three Tesoro's [size=small](a Bandido II, Bandido II microMAX and Silver Sabre microMAX)[/size] I keep a 6" Concentric coil mounted on each one of them, full-time. This is the so-named 5.75, but it actually measures 6" in diameter. On my other two brands of detectors I use mainly Double-D search coils except for two of them I have a Concentric coil.
For example, I mainly search old locations where there once were, but are no longer standing, structures such as houses, depots, stage stops, sheds, barns, stores, etc. Although they are gone, due to fire or demolition or tear-down to move them, left behind are many iron nails and other metal structure hardware [size=small](bolts, nits, screws, hinges, tin, etc., etc.)[/size] that needs to be handled and dealt with to gain best performance. I have found smaller coils excel over medium to larger coils on detector models that, by design, can handle these types of tough iron contaminated sites well.
A real-life challenge for any detector to try and handle is my
Nail Board Performance Test. I have been using it since Memorial Day of '94, and in 22 years [size=small](as
only ONE of several test scenarios I use that are based on actual in-the-field encounters)[/size] it has helped me, and others, learn about some of the strengths and weaknesses of different detectors or coils. In this case, how well they can handle,
or perhaps not handle, dense iron nail environments.
In this case, here on the Tesoro Forum, let's look at an example of a Tejón with a multiple search coil experiences. I already know what different makes and models and coil sizes and types have worked best for me through the years in the environments where I go Relic Hunting, and I have been a devoted fan of several Tesoro models since 1983, owning my top-three favorite Tesoro's today .... and keeping the most functional and capable coil mounted for the urban and non-urban challenges I typically go up against, the 6" Concentric.
Last year we had a
Welcome-to-Hunt Outing to three ghost towns in Nevada in September. These are open to anyone and they can use any detector they want, to which I add ... 'Good Luck!' One participant was aware of the abilities of some Tesoro models, and had seen some demonstrations I did on our
1st WTHO in May. He decided on a Tesoro Tejón and found a nice deal on a gently used Tejón 'package' that included the stock 8X9 Concentric spoked coil, and a few Double-D coils. Those included: Tesoro's NEW 8X11 DD, the Tesoro's 10" Elliptical DD as used on the Lobo SuperTRAQ, and a NEL Sharpshooter DD coil.
Let me add, if you don't mind, that many people in the hobby today have used or have considered using, a DD coil, quite often because they have hear good things about it from forum posters or a manufacturers ad, so they often have a perception, or perhaps we could say a misperception, of how a DD coil performs. Too often we hear terms like
"knife blade" precision or
"sees targets better in trash" or other encouragements of what they might be able to do, or how they might perform. or the EMF of the DD coil. One thing often not spoken of is just how well a coil might behave based upon how the detector circuitry is designed to work with different search coil sizes and types.
Anyway, I don't know what his personal experiences or feelings were at the time, but I suspect it favored a DD coil design. The night before our first ghost town hunt day at another site he had found a silver Barber dime. That's slightly smaller than an Indian Head penny, which was what I first located laying among the four iron nails back in '94. but it is also much more conductive than an IH penny.
He hadn't had the opportunity to really evaluate the Tejón and coils as he had just received it before the Outing, so we put the
NBPT on the ground in the ghost town, and he mounted one of the Tesoro DD coils to check out the performance. He adjusted the Threshold and Ground Balance, then the Discrimination setting to
just barely reject the four iron nails. Then he placed his silver Barber dime in the #1 circle in the center and checked out the Tejón/coil combination making the left-to-right and right-to-left sweeps across the entire
Nail Board, using all four directions.
To
ME, it requires 6 responses out of the possible 8 sweep directions to 'pass' this test, and I seldom use any detector and coil that can't provide at least 7 or 8 out of 8. First up was a failure. Honestly, you could say a total failure because when you only get 3 or 2, maybe 1 or 0 responses on 8 sweep directions, that's a failure. So, he switched coils and mounted the narrow Tesoro 10" Elliptical DD, checked the settings, and gave it a try on the
NBPT. Once again, he was rather shocked at the lack of performance. Ahh ... the after-market coil must be the answer, so he mounted the NEL Sharpshooter DD and worked it on the test, and THIS TIME ... he was, again, discouraged by the almost total lack of performance.
Here we were, at the start of a 5-day Outing with three or four ghost towns to hunt, and he didn't have a smaller 6" Concentric coil yet. I told him that a 6" Concentric would be the best coil choice for that model, or most any good Tesoro. Then I encouraged him to try the stock 8X9 Concentric coil. Note that 8X9 size is very close to or larger-than some of the other coils he had already used, but they were DD types. I knew then that he would be surprised because that coil gave him 8 out of 8 hits! A smaller 6" Concentric would do better in actual tough site challenges.
Back to you posted question:
It really depends on the site you are hunting, the density of trash, and where it is a lot of ferrous or non-ferrous you will deal with. The place you'll hunt might be wide-open and all targets, good and bad, are well spaced. This is what readers don't know, but ... If you are going to hunt modern trash at playgrounds or around picnicing areas, etc., I would suggest the 6" Concentric coil. If you are going to hunt any places with a lot of iron targets that might be closely positioned, I would suggest the 6" Concentric coil.
Monte