First in Auto or Manual. In auto the explorer will adjust the sensitivity quite a bit, as much as 12 or 16 steps, so running auto 25 might be the same as manual 10. Generally you can kick the sensitivity up much higher in auto and still have a stable detector. But in fact the detector is detuning and you aren't going to do any better than a lower manual setting. Where it is at depends on electrical noise and ground/trash conditions.
Also small coils tend to pick up less noise than large ones so you can usually turn the sensitivity up higher with a small coil than a larger one in any given area.
If you put the explorer in manual and turn the sensitivity down to the single digits and you are still getting chatter... try keeping the same settings and try a bigger coil. If the problem goes away it is a wiring problem in the coil.
I had the same problem with my stock coil. Just would not quiet down no matter what I did. Ended up resoldering the coil connector and now it is fine.
Chris