i dont have any other coils either other than the stock, but this seems like something where youd actually have to test out each coil at the same location, youd have to switch the coils to see if they each do the same thing.
id be very curious to know, like utah says above, what is the SUGGESTED sensitivity with each coil. if there is a huge difference at the same spot with each coil then id be afraid that something is wrong with the new coil. i hate to say that and i dont mean to frustrate or upset you.
i know its a pain but you need to swing each coil at the exact same location and see if they both do the same exact thing. is it possible that you have suddenly started hitting sites with a lot more junk and mineralization? the only way to tell is swap coils at that site. i have seen suggested sensitivity go anywhere from 9 to 31, so i guess my sites all vary widely, i know what its like to run at 9 and at 31, and anywhere in between. every site is different.
i would set the machine for manual 26 for your test. (NOT auto, for sure) sweep with each coil and listen for the chatter, compare the two. (try comparing at differents sens. levels, like manual 20, 15, etc.....just keep it the same for each coil) with each coil, toggle over and see what the "suggested" sensitivity is. i would imagine they should have the same amount of chatter and the suggested sens. should be similar. dont change anything on the machine during the test except for the coils. especially do not change the noise cancel channel. do not noise cancel for the test, leave it set where it is.