I have both... .That being said, I have used my 10x12 once or twice since I bought and received my larger 12x15. The reason being is that I get so much more out of the larger coil and it separates nearly as well as the small one.
If you are hunting trashy home sights or brush I would recommend the smaller one for smaller than coin sized objects.
The large one is plenty sensitive to coins, I found a .9 gram ring at 7" a day ago. This is with the large one and trash and iron present. The ring is less than half the weight of a dime.
I takes a little more work pinpointing but the 1-2" more in depth and 25-30 % larger detecting area has payed for itself. On large targets like the printing piece of lead I found, expect to find those targets at 12"+ all day long.
A person really needs to have both of them. If you swing the large one, buy yourself a swing thingy for $20 and you can go all day.
If you are hunting school fields, get the 10x12 so that you can pinpoint quicker and dig smaller holes. The pinpointing with the large coil can make some huge holes trying to find targets on their side or extremely deep.
I cant believe these guys didnt tell you to get the larger coil for hunting "fields". This coil is a must have and will find the smallest medium/high conductor at crazy depths.