This is all about "things."
Having the silencer is one of those "things" where you dont know you'll like it - til you have it. I don't use it much, as I like to hear the crackle of iron, but it has its place. We got into an old farm field last year, littered with iron. I mean an infestation.
It came in handy, then.
This whole "thing" depends on how you define cheap, too. I like the old Garret 2-mode Freedom detectors, but they are no better than anything else I have. And Garrett doesn't support them anymore, so service is iffy. At a cheap enough price they can be considered 'throwaways', but they aren't worth more money than that. It's just the way "things" are with them.
The 1235 is pretty much the same "thing" - defunct for reasons that are probably justified, and similar to the Garrett's. It doesn't mean it's bad, but if the cost is too dear, then you are paying good money for an aged mediocre detector... which doesn't sound like such a great "thing."