I have been using one in 2 completely different areas of the country for almost a year and a half.
In Birmingham Alabama, I used it from Jan to November last year and I got it for the extreme mineralization problems we have there.
The problem is, there are also veins of natural iron ore also running all over the area that choked back most every thing that is used around there.
My F2, My Compadre, the Vaq with this big coil, a friends E-Trac, guys with Whites units...in average soil nobody got much past 3-4 inches.
Some areas with better soil in the valleys we got deeper, but most of the sites I hunted 2-3 inches was average.
I can tell you the coil did seem to help quiet the Vaq down a lot because some parks I hunted the soil changed almost every 10 feet or so and the standard coil was much noisier and had to be continually balanced at these kinds of places.
I did learn to love that large scanning field, and I have confidence that I wasn't missing much when I hunted in larger areas.
It is a little heavier than the standard coil, but seems well balanced to me and I have never had a problem with the extra weight.
Now I have moved to Kansas with 1000x's better soil.
It seems at a few sites it has not been easy to GB, it all really sounds the same no matter where I turn that knob, but it isn't that way really because I did experiment with moving that knob up and down and after changing the settings I got deeper even though pumping that coil sounded the same no matter where I turned that knob.
Not sure what was going on there, but this only happens at a few sites, not most.
Something to do with this dirt I assume but what I have no idea.
I am going deeper here with all my detectors, but I am sorry to say I really can't give you any depth reports because mostly everything I have found with this coil in disc has usually been around 6 inches or less, maybe a few coins were a little deeper to about 8". but the standard concentric can hit that easily around here too.
I have always hunted in disc since I bought the Vaq because in Bama the threshold was not getting me any deeper.
I have begun experimenting with hunting that way now and as far as finding deep stuff it can sure do it, but pieces of iron have been all I have located so far on the few holes where I have gone real deep.
I still love that wide scanning field and just a few weeks ago at that same site where I was having the GB problems, evidently I had it set correctly that time because I only had a few minutes left so I just rushed all over this large field swinging wide and wild, moving fast with my disc down near iron.
I was hoping to roll over one good signal before I left, and I was hoping the fast recovery time on the Vaq would pick a good target up even at that fast speed.
Guess what...it worked!
Heard a quick solid tone and stopped and came back and dug one of my nicest an biggest gold rings.
Doing the same thing with my 9X8 concentric and covering way less real estate I probably never would have found this thing.
In mineralized soil you will get a bit deeper with the DD.
In good soil, the Concentrics will actually win the depth race, but not everything is always about depth and that wide field and great target separation on the DD coil makes me a fan forever and very happy I bought it.
Eventually I will try to take some time and bury some objects and test these two coils, but that might not be a great test because they are newly buried.
I will ask some guys at my next club meeting if they have a test garden I can try.
HH